Who is better Carpenter or J. Weaver

[ashliz]

thinking of dumping Carpenter for Weaver is it woth the move?

[visick]

Carp can go on 3 days rest and can hold his own vs. lefties.

If you throw Weaver in a hitting park facing 5-6 lefties, he'll be a cannon fodder.

[MEAT]

agree with visick, not nearly as sold on weaver as others, unless your league is ALL pitcher's parks. frightening number of ballpark taters...