If you had to choose one?

[dalekeener]

2010 Season/Draft league at SafeCo Field....If you had to choose one out of these 3 who would it be:

Uggla
Weeks
Johnson

I know...but those are my choices in this league.....

[chasenally]

Uggla and hope for more than 120 games out of him.

[Knerrpool]

It's pretty even, but I would say Johnson. Offensively they are close, but Johnson has the best defense, is the best versus RHP and is the cheapest (over $1M cheaper than Uggla )

[LMBombers]

I would go with Weeks. :lol:

[dalekeener]

Three responses, three different openions....kinda where I was..... :lol:

[Rant]

Not that much difference in my mind. All are above 600 PAs, none have a good card for your park. It depends a little on what you need.

If you want another lefty bat Johnson's the guy (and in your park this would be an advantage). Johnson also is the best fielder (negligible as it is) and has the best power against lefties. I don't like his unproductive outs, though.

Uggla will pick power if you have hitters parks in your division, has low dps, but is slow. Weeks is a good #2 hitter vs. lefties, but besides his low dps, speed, and * rating he's pretty weak against righties.

Roll a three-sided die.

[elpasopesos]

Johnson can lead off on the right. Weeks is a monster on the left and doesnt get injured. Uglla has a great card but has limitations

I pick based on how they fit in on your team L/R balance etc

[the splinter]

How about a cheap defensive specialist and an upgrade elsewhere?