I am starting my third league. At first I analyzed the players, and figured out which players were a better value for their cost. And then make some allowances to get players that fit my ball park. I thought that gave me the edge, and I sort of had things figured out. WRONG!
Now I see nowt is that this is where the real strategy begins. A player's real value has to do with the environment in which he is playing. That has to do with not only the park they play in, but with what type of pitchers and hitters dominate the league, and especially the division. On My first team, I chose Minute Maid for my park, and chose a bunch of guys who were good values, and whose skills fit Minute Maid. I picked nasty anti-righty pitchers like Chris Carpenter, Brandon Webb, Dustin Hermanson, and Francisco Rodney. They all have gotten shelled pretty consistently. What I didn't pick up on til recently, was that my league, and especially my division was filled with lefty parks, and lefty hitters. My great anti-righties were facing two righties per lineup, and getting beaten up by lefties. I just finaly traded Hermanson for Will Ohman, which looks like a dumb trade on paper, but I think will finally give me some sorely needed set-up against lefties.
On my second team I noticed my team was a little weak against lefty pitchers, and decided to put Jeff Francouer in my outfield to balance that. Francouer is top choice for MVP in my league at this point, leading the league in Total Bases by a significant amount, at first I thought it was just luck. Then I looked around, and relaized that my league was way overbalamced toward pitching, especially lefty statters on the strong teams. Francouer's numbers made sense.
So I am finally learning, that I can't just draft the best players. I have to draft the best plyaers for my environment, which means intelligent tinkering after the draft.
I'd love to hear some confirmations or reflections from other managers.