by keyzick » Tue Feb 01, 2011 9:44 am
I'm thinking you were looking for more of the "surprisingly good" type of players (ie, Mauer and Pujols are as good as their pricetag).
So, along those lines, I put together my list, by position, of the players who I think consistently peroformed at a level higher than their pricetags:
[b:f20926e89b]C [/b:f20926e89b] [b:f20926e89b]AJ Pierzynski[/b:f20926e89b] - I think it's a matter of lefties getting to face righties about 2/3 of the time
[b:f20926e89b]1B Joey Votto[/b:f20926e89b] - he's a $6M+ guy, but puts up huge numbers as long as he avoids the DL
[b:f20926e89b]2B Freddy Sanchez[/b:f20926e89b] (v LHP) - great platoon player
[b:f20926e89b]SS A. Ramirez[/b:f20926e89b] (v LHP)/[b:f20926e89b]C. Pennington[/b:f20926e89b] (v RHP) - great combo platoon, can combine for some astounding offensive figures (if you don't mind a 3 at ss)
[b:f20926e89b]3B Mark Reynolds[/b:f20926e89b] - always puts up 40+ HRs, and can give you a decent avg and obp in the right park too, as long as you don't mind the 4e24!
[b:f20926e89b]RF Shin-Soo Choo[/b:f20926e89b] - great offense, and arm on defense
[b:f20926e89b]CF Carlos Beltran[/b:f20926e89b] - big injury risk who, mysteriously, does not seem to get injured that much. I think I've gotten 500+ abs out of him every time...and his card is relatively cheaper because of the injury risk
[b:f20926e89b]LF Carlos Gonzalez[/b:f20926e89b] - ok, I cheated here, couldn't think of any LF's that surprised me. I THINK Gonzalez qualifies in left (although I use him in CF)...great fielder and offensive stats (in the right park)
[b:f20926e89b]DH Chris Coghlan[/b:f20926e89b] - sub $4M guy who can give you .300+/.400+/.400+ every time
[b:f20926e89b]SP Jorge De La Rosa[/b:f20926e89b] - LOVE Tejeda, but had to put De La Rosa based on his sub-$2M price tag, and can consistently put up very good numbers if you go the pitchers park route
[b:f20926e89b]CL Chad Qualls[/b:f20926e89b] - Can almost always get him, is cheap, and good for 30-40 saves per season
I didn't bother with an [b:f20926e89b]RP[/b:f20926e89b]....seems like there are just so many out there I couldn't zero in on just one...maybe [b:f20926e89b]Fulchino[/b:f20926e89b] for his price?
Anyway that's my 2 cents!