Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

2007 Jones or Wells, who would you rather have in CF?

to take it one step further, taking price, stats, def, ect.. into considertaion rank these 4

Wells, Jones, Cameron, Hunter. I've had some experience with all 4. The most with Jones and the least (12 games) with Cameron. I can't come to a fair conclusion yet, but so far I'd have to go like this.

1. Wells
2. Hunter
3. Jones
4. Cameron

As mentioned it's not really a fair comparison yet, as they played in different park, and a couple of the judgements are made on incomplete seasons. I have not included other CF's as these 4 are fairly close in cost, Def, and all right handed hitters.

other opinions for those who have used more than one of them.

they're all so overpriced its almost unbearable. Ive had some success with wells, who atleast occassionally hits for a decent average with some power. obviously all are pretty strong defensively, but ive never seen any hit consistently over .250, and ive got cammeron hitting 8th or 9th on one team, and he's STILL under-producing. wells I hit cleanup when he's going good, bottom 3rd when he's sucking along at .220.

i'd take jones. he's going hit the most HR's. All of them are going to struggle as far as avg is a concern.