by JdEarly » Sat Oct 01, 2005 5:31 pm
Hi, Doc. Nice to talk to ya. Here's my thoughts for your team right now:
1. Eric Gagne isn't going to be worth anything near his price tag for you in Shea. I would allow Rivera to close games for you on the road, but is B.J. Ryan available to swap Gagne for? I think the lefty-righty combo at the back of your pen would be more than solid.
2. If, by chance, you can't pick up a better defensive 1B than Thome, and plan on keeping the Valent/Merloni platoon at DH, I would recommend that you flip them. Thome at DH, the platoon at 1B. Merloni and Valent aren't going to win you any gold gloves, but their range is average and they don't drop many balls that they get to.
3. As was posted earlier in this thread, David Bell and Damion Easley should be cast aside. Those two, along with Miguel Tejada, could help you set the record for errors on an infield in one season. Scary stuff. Orlando Hudson is usually available, and even though he's got a 2 injury rating, he would really solidify your "up the middle" defense. At 3B, a guy like Eric Chavez would be ideal, but even Jose Hernandez would be a better bet than Bell. He strikes out a ton, but one out is better than the DP's Bell is sure to hit into at costly times.
4. I really like the Torrealba/Valentin platoon. I'm in the middle of a couple of seasons with it (Coors, Shea) and would recommend it to anyone, in any park, unless they're going with an elite catcher or Jason Kendall. Less than $3 million, and you're playing them to their strengths every night. Great choice.
5. Angel Berroa? Really?
6. I've had Schilling in Miller Park, which plays like a mini-Shea, and he posted... decent... numbers for me. Nothing to spectacular, a high number of losses but solid stats otherwise. I won that division with 84 wins, lucky enough. I'd say stick with Schilling, but temper your expectations. If you're able to get Doug Davis for him, I'd say give that a shot and pick up a solid righty to spot start in addition to him, someone who can work out of the pen effectively in the weeks and months between their starts.
7. Brad Radke in Shea... I have never tried it, never had the stomach to. He doesn't walk a lot of batters, but gives up a ton of hits. For a right hander in Shea, that's some scary stuff. If you've got the stones, by all means. I've never heard of anyone using him in Shea, so, again, I could be wrong.
8. Mark Mulder should be the surprise of your pitching staff. Some people don't like him in Shea, but he's your number 4 starter. Expect him to post numbers similar to that of a number 2. I would recommend him in Shea eight days a week.
9. Kerry Robinson... let him run, and run him often. The guy steals bases like a mad man when given the opportunity.
In closing, your roster is already pretty solid, but in all honesty it looks like you have a lot more money to play with in free agency than you figure to have right now. Even if no one wants Juan Rivera from you, he's got a high price tag, so before the season starts he is of great value to you. Costs almost a million more than Burntiz, who would give you HUGE numbers.
Good luck, and I hope I helped.