by MICHAELTARBELL » Fri Oct 14, 2005 1:29 pm
Aray, welcome to SOM online!
agree with Mo, Minute Maid and Shea are what we refer to as "extreme" parks, meaning that they heavily favor one side over the other in BPHR potential. In the case of Minute Maid, it favors right handed batters over left handed batters (1-4 for LH, 1-13 for RH). With this in mind, you will want a staff that is tough on right handers, but can be somewhat lax vs lefties, especially where bphr's are concerned, since in MM, most of these will turn into long flyball outs.
In looking at your pitching staff, it looks more like a Shea staff, with predominantly lh starters. I would revamp, and look for starters that are right handed. The reason is simple, most right handers do not hit right handed pitching as well as they do left handed pitching. Guys like Garcia, Westbrook, Pavano, Maddux, etc (on the lower end)...are good choices here. If you want a lefty, a reverse lefty (Pettitte) would work well here.
On offense, you do not look too bad, and have the right idea by loading up on righties. Ortiz is ok, decent natural power vs righties, and will make people hesitate a bit to throw a cheapo righty at you! :wink: Look for a guy that is right handed, and hits righties well, since with so many rh batters, you will see alot of them! A. Ramirez is a great value here, Beltre on the expensive end, but same idea. Jeff Bagwell (with a platoon) fits well here also....
To answer your initial question, do I prefer a 4 or 5 man rotation, it depends on the situation. But I would say in general, 4 game starters are a better value than the 5 game starters in this years set, especially at the higher end. As opposed to the 2003 set, where I felt the 5 game starters were a better value. :) :wink:
Good luck, and have fun!