Boone vs. Belliard, who's better?

[Play By The Rules]

Let me ask about two scenarios:

1) Neutral park

2) Shea

Just curious about what the vets think, maybe I've been wrong about this one!

[JOELKING]

Belliard, better, however you want better defence, then go with boone.

[Play By The Rules]

That is not an answer.

Who is better, OVERALL, Belliard or Boone?

[LMBombers]

Belliard is a better option in any park IMO.

[Play By The Rules]

Now THAT'S an answer. :wink:

[Play By The Rules]

C'mon vets, let me hear you, I'm sure you have an opinion...

[geekor]

LOL

can't let an arguemnt go eh?

anyways I really think the question is too broad. If both were sitting in the Fa list, it would depend on wha tthe rest of my team looks like. Neither one is a high pick for me.

Neutral park, probably Boone, bat him 7th or 8th. Shea Proabably Belliard, unless my lineup was stacked 1-7 then Boone and bat him 8th. this is unless I need another hitter vs lefties with some obp, then Belliard.

[Play By The Rules]

Actually it wasn't an argument at all, I stated Boone was better as a broadly accepted fact, and I'm trying to find out if I am wrong.

So far I am surprised at the responses. You learn something every day.

[LMBombers]

Belliard will hit 40 doubles and have a higher OBP than Boone. I have had excellent results with Belliard.

http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/baseball/stratomatic/2005/team/team_other.html?user_id=10683

43 doubles and 18 HRs in Shea

http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/baseball/stratomatic/2005/team/team_other.html?user_id=19543

49 doubles and 17 HRs in Miller Park

http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/baseball/stratomatic/2005/team/team_other.html?user_id=22705

37 doubles and 12 HRs in Shea (his worst performance for me)

[STEPHENANDERSON 2]

Belliard by far.... had Boonie once and Belliard 3 or 4 times in various stadiums.

Pick up late season .394 in 94 AB 4 HR in minute maid
.293 16HR 98 RBIS in COORS - 646 ABs 17 E's
.259 11HR 69 RBI i Minute Maid - 586 AB 15 E's

Boone I dropped after 43 games 4 HR 10 RBis 27 hits not sure errors in Shea Stadium.


Hope that helps. Thats my opinion after 4 different teams.