Settings When Your Closer Isn't Your Best RP?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c872e/c872e2f13cf94b00f5f3db4cdc6b34abb2c8f449" alt="Post Post"
I'm doing pretty well so far with this Wrigley team (48 games into the season):
THELONIOUS MONKS
http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/baseball/stratomatic/2005/team/team_other.html?user_id=41501
But I've toyed with different manager settings, trying to get optimal usage out of my pen. I've of course got Gordon as setup both ways. He's a gem. But I can't seem to get much work out of Hoffman or Cerda. I had Hoffman originally set to close both ways. Then I had Hoffman set to close vs. righties, and Cerda against lefties. Then more recently I've just left the closer options blank. Gordon's getting mucho innings, and that's great. But however I've set the closer settings, HAL seems to more or less equally spread around the balance of the available innings. In fact, Elmer Dessens and then Buddy Groom are the next leading innings eaters in my pen so far - not something I'm particularly happy with when Hoffman and Cerda are just sitting there eating sunflower seeds...I have not marked their player cards in any way. Any suggestions?
THELONIOUS MONKS
http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/baseball/stratomatic/2005/team/team_other.html?user_id=41501
But I've toyed with different manager settings, trying to get optimal usage out of my pen. I've of course got Gordon as setup both ways. He's a gem. But I can't seem to get much work out of Hoffman or Cerda. I had Hoffman originally set to close both ways. Then I had Hoffman set to close vs. righties, and Cerda against lefties. Then more recently I've just left the closer options blank. Gordon's getting mucho innings, and that's great. But however I've set the closer settings, HAL seems to more or less equally spread around the balance of the available innings. In fact, Elmer Dessens and then Buddy Groom are the next leading innings eaters in my pen so far - not something I'm particularly happy with when Hoffman and Cerda are just sitting there eating sunflower seeds...I have not marked their player cards in any way. Any suggestions?