Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

who is better for networkasc park ,,,, agasint shea,petco,busch

mabry or brian giles

Probably Giles but I don't know. Mabry sucked for me and I had him IN Petco.

i have giles now and will use kielty as his sub agasint LH..so im onlu using giles against righties...

but maybe could use mabry against both and spend $$$ elsewhere

Giles by a large margain. Have a good platoon.

yes thank you PBTR.....

I am all over Mabry for LF. I have had tremendous success with him. Giles and Keilty is a great idea, but I try to have Mabry on my teams.

I've used Hammonds in RF as well in hitter's parks vs L, paired up with Giles.
When playing in a lefty park, just keep Giles in there.

But Kielty's a good (slightly better) choice.

The problem with Hammond is the injury.

I don't have Mabry on any team at the moment but he was great for me at Petco, he hit.292 with 27 HRs and 96 RBI's. So it is interesting that people have very different opinions. I had Giles once and he was most unimpressive. His OBP never materialized.