1st Draft - Either I'm the best drafter ever or the worst...

1st Draft - Either I'm the best drafter ever or the worst...

Postby mille1212 » Sat Aug 06, 2011 12:24 am

Well folks. Thanks for all the input earlier. I have now officially completed my very first autodraft. So glad I asked questions first...

I played the 90's mystery card game, which I know adds a level of complexity. Now I am off to figure that part out next... Is there a mystery card board somewhere?

At any rate, I must either be the best drafter ever or the worst since I got 23 out of the 25 players that I wanted in the draft. I'm thinking it must be the latter :shock:

I missed out on John Franco (Lefty-1.86 mil), my 3rd best reliever. I got Jeff Reardon instead (Righty-1.79 mil).

I also missed out on R Wilkins (Left hitter-2.81 mil), my catcher. I got Mike Lieberthal instead (Right hitter-2.71 mil).

I only have $170,000 remaining now since I got everyone I wanted. It seems like I should have more than that in reserve for a long season. I am considering letting Reardon go to pick up a lefty like I orginally wanted as my 3rd best reliever. Any thoughts on that?

Anyway, let me know what you think, best or worst (or anywhere in between :) . Any recommendations for improvement would be appreciated. I went with a 40 mil pitching and 40 mil hitting strategy. For good or bad, we'll see how that works out.

http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/team/team_other.html?user_id=340286
mille1212
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby chasenally » Sat Aug 06, 2011 1:59 am

I looked at your team for 8 seconds and here is what I see. You spent way too much on SP for the park you play in. It took me 4 seconds to check out the park you play in. When you play in a pitchers park high priced pitchers are not needed. You want high batting average, OBP hitters that can steal bases and play small ball. I believe you will get killed, sorry.
I hope you get these guys best cards as you will be needing them.

I hope you get some help from those that play the 90's game [b:e424b0c1f0]HELP HIM 90's GUYS[/b:e424b0c1f0]. Just looking at your line up tells me that you only have 8 guys that can start in your batting order and everyone else is under 1mil. Even with that I don't see many runs for you. I would dump 2 of your SP or ECK as you will not be needing both SP and Closer when you have both that are very good. Your SP will complete so many games that ECK will grow mold sitting on the bench. That is 7mil that could get you better offense of keep ECK and drop 2 SP and put 10mil in your batting order.
Take a look at what you have and the park you play in. Do you really have enough bat or will you need to shutout those steriod injecting monsters to win the game? Look at the other parks in your division and if they are hitters parks you will need to shut them out to win.
I am sure that you will get help from those that play the 90's game. Even the ones in your division will help you. Email the teams in your league and ask for advice. They will help you as they want you to suceed and play more teams in the 90's league as they love that league and want more players for more leagues. I promise you they do!

Good luck, Mike
Last edited by chasenally on Sat Aug 06, 2011 2:14 am, edited 1 time in total.
chasenally
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby mille1212 » Sat Aug 06, 2011 2:06 am

One vote for the worst... lol... Just as I figured...

[quote:375e507c49="chasenally"]I looked at your team for 8 seconds and here is what I see. You spent way too much on SP for the park you play in. It took me 4 seconds to check out the park you play in. When you play in a pitchers park high priced pitchers are not needed. You want high batting average, OBP hitters that can steal bases and play small ball. I believe you will get killed, sorry.
I hope you get these guys best cards as you will be needing them.[/quote:375e507c49]
mille1212
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby chasenally » Sat Aug 06, 2011 2:23 am

I sent you a PM. When you click on this site you will see an envelope in the upper left corner of the screen. Click on it and you will see it.

Mike
chasenally
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby durantjerry » Sat Aug 06, 2011 9:10 am

Sp's-Schilling and Brown are good. I would downgrade Glavine and Key for cheaper and use the $$$ for hitters. Gullickson is a good pick. I would take a shot with him early in the Dome to see if you can get lucky and get one of his good years. Starting him at home will neutralize some of the bombs he gives up if you catch one of the bad years. It's tough to win with that much $$$ spent on pitching. You'll have to get very lucky with you hiiters even assuming you get the good pitching years. Some cheaper * pitchers to look for(but are probably gone) are Drabek, Swindell and Kile. Others that are OK are Morgan, Hamilton and Fassero. Again, the Dome gives you the luxury of limiting the risk of testing out high risk/high reward guys like Nomo and Park(or cheaper). These are guys who walk a lot of guys and give up the HR in a few of their bad years, which will be limited in the Dome and you could catch their dominant good year.
RP-Eck of course is top of the line. Downside is the cost. If you can manage the cost he is a keeper. More than a few cheaper closers have Eck type seasons for a couple of years on their cards. A guy you might want to give a try in the Dome is Benitez, as he's cheap, has some real good years and his weakness is #HR's and walks, both of which are less of a problem in the Dome. I rarely use the other guys in your pen. Cheap guys I like are Quantrill, Wendall, Eichhorn, Patterson(L) for < $1.00. For over $1.00 some I like are Cook and Seanez among others.
OF-Greer is very good. With Grissom, you almost need his good year for him to be worth it. Mondesi can be good but is better suited for a power park.
IF-Gallaraga, I never have any luck with him, but he plays good "D" and has two nice years. Lansing is usually the last guy picked, as he's pretty consistently mediocre. There are a lot of cheap usable 2B as well as some very good expensive 2B so you should be able to do better. I like Ozzie. You should know pretty fast from the stats if it's good Ozzie or bad Ozzie. I don't use Caminetti much because even his good years have injury and balance issues(slanted vs LH/RH). 3B is a little thin and you need a little luck if you don't have one of the top guys.
C-Lieberthal must go
Here are a couple of my Astrodome teams to see what I did right(and wrong). You will see all the money I spent on offense and my teams are still only ninth and twelth respectively in the offensive rankings.
[url]http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/team/team_other.html?user_id=334060[/url]
[url]http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/team/team_other.html?user_id=309372[/url]
durantjerry
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby mille1212 » Sat Aug 06, 2011 9:35 am

Wow. Thank you. That was very helpful. I'll get on trying to improve the team.

[quote:be8eca9f60="durantjerry"]Sp's-Schilling and Brown are good. I would downgrade Glavine and Key for cheaper and use the $$$ for hitters. Gullickson is a good pick. I would take a shot with him early in the Dome to see if you can get lucky and get one of his good years. Starting him at home will neutralize some of the bombs he gives up if you catch one of the bad years. It's tough to win with that much $$$ spent on pitching. You'll have to get very lucky with you hiiters even assuming you get the good pitching years. Some cheraper * pitchers to look for(but are probably gone) are Drabek, Swindell and Kile. Others that are OK are Morgan, Hamilton and Fassero. Again, the Dome gives you the luxury of limiting the risk of testing out high risk/high reward guys like Nomo and Park(or cheaper). These are guys who walk a lot of guys and give up the HR in a few of their bad years, which will be limited in the Dome and you could catch their dominant good year.
RP-Eck of course is top of the line. Downside is the cost. If you can manage the cost he is a keeper. More than a few cheaper closers have Eck type seasons for a couple of years on their cards. A guy you might want to give a try in the Dome is Benitez, as he's cheap, has some real good years and his weakness is #HR's and walks, both of which are less of a problem in the Dome. I rarely use the other guys in your pen. Cheap guys I like are Quantrill, Wendall, Eichhorn, Patterson(L) for < $1.00. For over $1.00 some I like are Cook and Seanez among others.
OF-Greer is very good. With Grissom, you almost need his good year for him to be worth it. Mondesi can be good but is better suited for a power park.
IF-Gallaraga, I never have any luck with him, but he plays good "D" and has two nice years. Lansing is usually the last guy picked, as he's pretty consistently mediocre. There are a lot of cheap usable 2B as well as some very good expensive 2B so you should be able to do better. I like Ozzie. You should know pretty fast from the stats if it's good Ozzie or bad Ozzie. I don't use Caminetti much because even his good years have injury and balance issues(slanted vs LH/RH). 3B is a little thin and you need a little luck if you don't have one of the top guys.
C-Lieberthal must go
Here are a couple of my Astrodome teams to see what I did right(and wrong). You will see all the money I spent on offense and my teams are still only ninth and twelth respectively in the offensive rankings.
[url]http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/team/team_other.html?user_id=334060[/url]
[url]http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/team/team_other.html?user_id=309372[/url][/quote:be8eca9f60]
mille1212
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby mille1212 » Sat Aug 06, 2011 9:37 am

Thanks for the tips. I think I'm going to try and drop the two SPs as you've suggest to bolster the batting.

[quote:577c1ace45="chasenally"]I looked at your team for 8 seconds and here is what I see. You spent way too much on SP for the park you play in. It took me 4 seconds to check out the park you play in. When you play in a pitchers park high priced pitchers are not needed. You want high batting average, OBP hitters that can steal bases and play small ball. I believe you will get killed, sorry.
I hope you get these guys best cards as you will be needing them.

I hope you get some help from those that play the 90's game [b:577c1ace45]HELP HIM 90's GUYS[/b:577c1ace45]. Just looking at your line up tells me that you only have 8 guys that can start in your batting order and everyone else is under 1mil. Even with that I don't see many runs for you. I would dump 2 of your SP or ECK as you will not be needing both SP and Closer when you have both that are very good. Your SP will complete so many games that ECK will grow mold sitting on the bench. That is 7mil that could get you better offense of keep ECK and drop 2 SP and put 10mil in your batting order.
Take a look at what you have and the park you play in. Do you really have enough bat or will you need to shutout those steriod injecting monsters to win the game? Look at the other parks in your division and if they are hitters parks you will need to shut them out to win.
I am sure that you will get help from those that play the 90's game. Even the ones in your division will help you. Email the teams in your league and ask for advice. They will help you as they want you to suceed and play more teams in the 90's league as they love that league and want more players for more leagues. I promise you they do!

Good luck, Mike[/quote:577c1ace45]
mille1212
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby hallerose » Sat Aug 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Name T End. W L S IP H R ER BB SO HR ERA WHIP BAL Salary
Brown, Kevin R S7* 18 10 0 248.1 222 0 78 58 190 12 2.91 1.15 1R 8.27M KEEP, ONE OF THE TOP STARTERS.
Schilling, Curt R S7* 17 9 0 239.0 215 0 88 52 250 27 3.38 1.13 E 6.57M PROBABLY KEEP, BUT WATCH HIS YEARS EARLY TO SEE IF YOU HAVE A GOOD ONE.
Glavine, Tom L S7* 18 9 0 222.1 206 0 75 77 152 13 3.16 1.29 3R 6.26M SOLID, BUT PROBABLY FIND SOMEONE CHEAPER.
Key, Jimmy L S7* 15 9 0 200.0 196 0 77 51 126 19 3.46 1.23 3L 5.89M FIND SOMEONE CHEAPER.
Gullickson, Bill R S7* 14 11 0 209.0 227 0 95 52 84 26 4.09 1.33 2R .75M YOU PROBABLY WANT A 5TH STARTER WHO CAN PITCH IN RELIEF. MAYBE A VERY SLANTED L OR R GUY.
Eckersley, Dennis R R2/C6 5 2 44 72.0 49 9 15 8 76 6 1.88 0.79 4R 6.19M TOO EXPENSIVE, ESPECIALLY WITH YOUR STARTERS.
Henneman, Mike R R2/C5 7 5 23 84.0 77 0 27 29 57 5 2.90 1.26 2R 1.87M OK TO KEEP, BUT NOT GREAT.
Reardon, Jeff R R1/C6 3 3 32 60.0 56 0 22 14 42 7 3.31 1.17 1R 1.79M SOLID.
Clontz, Brad R R2/C0 4 2 2 54.1 54 0 26 22 40 6 4.32 1.40 7R .75M SET AS RIGHTY SPECIALIST.
Myers, Mike L R1/C1 1 3 3 50.1 47 0 23 24 46 5 4.13 1.42 6L .75M SET AS LEFTY SPECIALIST.

Hitters (14) min. 13, max. 17
Name B P Def. AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS BA OBP SLG BAL Salary
Lieberthal, Mike R C 3(-1)e4 251 34 68 15 1 12 41 21 40 1 1 .270 .331 .474 1L 2.71M NEED TO UPGRADE.
Parent, Mark R C 4(0)e4 161 15 37 7 0 7 21 14 38 0 0 .232 .292 .405 3L .88M TRY TO GET BETTER DEFENSE AS BACK UP CATCHER.
Galarraga, Andres R 1B 1e13 546 81 159 30 2 28 99 41 138 9 4 .290 .351 .506 2L 6.10M WATCH CLOSELY IF YOU GET ONE OF HIS GOOD YEARS, IF NOT CUT IN SEASON.
Lansing, Mike R 2B 2e11 532 70 146 35 2 12 57 37 73 17 6 .274 .327 .413 1L 3.55M IS BIGGIO, ALOMAR AVAILABLE. HIGH OBP AND GOOD D HERE.
Duncan, Mariano S 2B 3e23 437 60 121 23 5 10 53 16 78 11 4 .277 .307 .419 3L .75M PROBABLY DON'T NEED 2 BACK UP 2B, CHOOSE ONE.
McLemore, Mark S 2B 3e14 437 70 114 17 3 4 39 64 64 15 7 .261 .356 .341 1R .75M
Hale, Chip L 2B 4e38 112 12 32 5 0 1 15 11 13 0 1 .282 .351 .371 5R .75M CUT, MAYBE FIND A LEFTY PLOOTON FOR DH (E.G., MIESKE, GWILLIAMS)
Caminiti, Ken S 3B 1e22 454 61 123 24 1 12 64 46 76 7 4 .271 .337 .411 E 3.62M TRY TO UPGRADE, BUT 3B IS THIN POSITION.
Arias, Alex R 3B 3e18 179 19 47 6 1 2 20 17 19 1 1 .265 .335 .342 1R .75M TOO MANY INFIELD BACK UPS.
Smith, Ozzie S SS 2e19 422 55 114 17 3 1 35 44 25 21 6 .270 .337 .330 E 1.42M CHEAP AND GOOD DEF. I LIKE HIM.
Greer, Rusty L LF 2(0)e8 543 96 167 35 4 19 91 75 80 5 2 .308 .392 .490 E 5.87M SOLID, GOOD OBP.
Owens, Eric R LF 3(+1)e6 337 45 89 13 2 4 30 28 44 18 6 .264 .322 .350 1L .75M NOTHING SPECIAL.
Grissom, Marquis R CF 1(-2)e6 599 90 164 28 4 14 65 45 83 52 11 .274 .325 .405 1L 5.37M I HAVEN'T SEEN HIM LIVE UP TO HIS CARDS. LOOK AT OPTIONS, OR CUT IF HE DOESN'T PERFORM.
Mondesi, Raul R RF 2(-5)e8 553 86 158 29 6 27 84 39 105 24 9 .286 .334 .506 2R 6.72M OK, BUT PREFER HIM OBP GUY IN YOUR BALLPARK. E.G., GWYNN.

ON YOU UPGRADES LOOK FOR GOOD DEFENSE AND HIGH OBP SINCE YOU HOPE TO PLAY A LOT OF LOW SCORING GAMES IN THE ASTRODOME.
YOU DON'T APPEAR TO HAVE A DH. IF YOU ARE IN A DH LEAGUE, FIND A HIGH OPS GUY(S) WHO IS 4 ON DEFENSE. MAYBE CAN PLATOON SO NOT WASTING SO MUCH MONEY WITH GUYS WHO WILL GET A FEW ABS (YOU HAVE 6 .75 GUYS WHO YOU DON'T WANT TO PLAY, TRY TO LIMIT TO 2 OR 3 WITH A COUPLE PLATOONS).
hallerose
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby mille1212 » Sat Aug 06, 2011 11:40 pm

Thanks again for the tips. If only they didn't limit you to 8 waiver selections. I will have to insure that I fill my highest priorities this first go around for waivers. After that I will start to address some of the other minor areas. Unfortunately, I will have to take the 5% hit on some of those smaller drop suggestions you've made since I won't be able to do it all the first week.

[quote:85c7450661="hallerose"]Name T End. W L S IP H R ER BB SO HR ERA WHIP BAL Salary
Brown, Kevin R S7* 18 10 0 248.1 222 0 78 58 190 12 2.91 1.15 1R 8.27M KEEP, ONE OF THE TOP STARTERS.
Schilling, Curt R S7* 17 9 0 239.0 215 0 88 52 250 27 3.38 1.13 E 6.57M PROBABLY KEEP, BUT WATCH HIS YEARS EARLY TO SEE IF YOU HAVE A GOOD ONE.
Glavine, Tom L S7* 18 9 0 222.1 206 0 75 77 152 13 3.16 1.29 3R 6.26M SOLID, BUT PROBABLY FIND SOMEONE CHEAPER.
Key, Jimmy L S7* 15 9 0 200.0 196 0 77 51 126 19 3.46 1.23 3L 5.89M FIND SOMEONE CHEAPER.
Gullickson, Bill R S7* 14 11 0 209.0 227 0 95 52 84 26 4.09 1.33 2R .75M YOU PROBABLY WANT A 5TH STARTER WHO CAN PITCH IN RELIEF. MAYBE A VERY SLANTED L OR R GUY.
Eckersley, Dennis R R2/C6 5 2 44 72.0 49 9 15 8 76 6 1.88 0.79 4R 6.19M TOO EXPENSIVE, ESPECIALLY WITH YOUR STARTERS.
Henneman, Mike R R2/C5 7 5 23 84.0 77 0 27 29 57 5 2.90 1.26 2R 1.87M OK TO KEEP, BUT NOT GREAT.
Reardon, Jeff R R1/C6 3 3 32 60.0 56 0 22 14 42 7 3.31 1.17 1R 1.79M SOLID.
Clontz, Brad R R2/C0 4 2 2 54.1 54 0 26 22 40 6 4.32 1.40 7R .75M SET AS RIGHTY SPECIALIST.
Myers, Mike L R1/C1 1 3 3 50.1 47 0 23 24 46 5 4.13 1.42 6L .75M SET AS LEFTY SPECIALIST.

Hitters (14) min. 13, max. 17
Name B P Def. AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS BA OBP SLG BAL Salary
Lieberthal, Mike R C 3(-1)e4 251 34 68 15 1 12 41 21 40 1 1 .270 .331 .474 1L 2.71M NEED TO UPGRADE.
Parent, Mark R C 4(0)e4 161 15 37 7 0 7 21 14 38 0 0 .232 .292 .405 3L .88M TRY TO GET BETTER DEFENSE AS BACK UP CATCHER.
Galarraga, Andres R 1B 1e13 546 81 159 30 2 28 99 41 138 9 4 .290 .351 .506 2L 6.10M WATCH CLOSELY IF YOU GET ONE OF HIS GOOD YEARS, IF NOT CUT IN SEASON.
Lansing, Mike R 2B 2e11 532 70 146 35 2 12 57 37 73 17 6 .274 .327 .413 1L 3.55M IS BIGGIO, ALOMAR AVAILABLE. HIGH OBP AND GOOD D HERE.
Duncan, Mariano S 2B 3e23 437 60 121 23 5 10 53 16 78 11 4 .277 .307 .419 3L .75M PROBABLY DON'T NEED 2 BACK UP 2B, CHOOSE ONE.
McLemore, Mark S 2B 3e14 437 70 114 17 3 4 39 64 64 15 7 .261 .356 .341 1R .75M
Hale, Chip L 2B 4e38 112 12 32 5 0 1 15 11 13 0 1 .282 .351 .371 5R .75M CUT, MAYBE FIND A LEFTY PLOOTON FOR DH (E.G., MIESKE, GWILLIAMS)
Caminiti, Ken S 3B 1e22 454 61 123 24 1 12 64 46 76 7 4 .271 .337 .411 E 3.62M TRY TO UPGRADE, BUT 3B IS THIN POSITION.
Arias, Alex R 3B 3e18 179 19 47 6 1 2 20 17 19 1 1 .265 .335 .342 1R .75M TOO MANY INFIELD BACK UPS.
Smith, Ozzie S SS 2e19 422 55 114 17 3 1 35 44 25 21 6 .270 .337 .330 E 1.42M CHEAP AND GOOD DEF. I LIKE HIM.
Greer, Rusty L LF 2(0)e8 543 96 167 35 4 19 91 75 80 5 2 .308 .392 .490 E 5.87M SOLID, GOOD OBP.
Owens, Eric R LF 3(+1)e6 337 45 89 13 2 4 30 28 44 18 6 .264 .322 .350 1L .75M NOTHING SPECIAL.
Grissom, Marquis R CF 1(-2)e6 599 90 164 28 4 14 65 45 83 52 11 .274 .325 .405 1L 5.37M I HAVEN'T SEEN HIM LIVE UP TO HIS CARDS. LOOK AT OPTIONS, OR CUT IF HE DOESN'T PERFORM.
Mondesi, Raul R RF 2(-5)e8 553 86 158 29 6 27 84 39 105 24 9 .286 .334 .506 2R 6.72M OK, BUT PREFER HIM OBP GUY IN YOUR BALLPARK. E.G., GWYNN.

ON YOU UPGRADES LOOK FOR GOOD DEFENSE AND HIGH OBP SINCE YOU HOPE TO PLAY A LOT OF LOW SCORING GAMES IN THE ASTRODOME.
YOU DON'T APPEAR TO HAVE A DH. IF YOU ARE IN A DH LEAGUE, FIND A HIGH OPS GUY(S) WHO IS 4 ON DEFENSE. MAYBE CAN PLATOON SO NOT WASTING SO MUCH MONEY WITH GUYS WHO WILL GET A FEW ABS (YOU HAVE 6 .75 GUYS WHO YOU DON'T WANT TO PLAY, TRY TO LIMIT TO 2 OR 3 WITH A COUPLE PLATOONS).[/quote:85c7450661]
mille1212
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Postby Mr Baseball World » Sat Aug 06, 2011 11:47 pm

You can make as many moves as you want after waivers but before the season starts so you will be able to make all moves without the 5% hit.
Mr Baseball World
 
Posts: 55
Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm

Next

Return to Strat-O-Matic Baseball Online 20xx

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests

cron