Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

Given a choice, which would you take?

Hmm ... wonder why you're asking?!! ... :P

[quote:7833153c26="AeroDave10"]Hmm ... wonder why you're asking?!! ... :P[/quote:7833153c26]


So c'mon and help me out! :-) I am leaning Rollins, but have never really liked him much so am intrigued w/ Aybar.

I don't think either one is a great value, but at least you get 600 PAs with J-Roll.

I was thinking that too, but they are both listed as "1"'s for injury? Is there a different formulat that AB+BB for the 2011 game?

They both have the same chance of getting hurt in terms of the dice rolls. It's just that the maximum number of games Rollins can miss at one time is 3. The maximum number of games Aybar (and all players w/ less than 600 PAs) can miss at one time is 15.

Having already taken Andrus in that draft...I wouldn't take either of them. :wink:

But as a Phillies fan, Rollins is still a good glove, but his bat stinks, and has stunk ever since his MVP. In strat, Aybar is a better option, but has the 15-game injury risk. I don't see a lot of guys picking up Rollins in the $80M leagues, but maybe in the $100M he might be okay.

SS is very weak in this set. I would maybe take 2 and rotate then or I went with Starling and just let him play.

Depends what you need, I suppose. I'll usually take the guy who can get the hits (Aybar with 33+, better TB), but Rollins has a slightly better steal rating and less DPs and Ks, +clutch, a better e rating. They both stink against lefties. Flip a coin.

Would Elvis Andrus be a better option then Rollins and Aybar? Lets say while using Yankee Stadium?