Avoid lefty/righty??
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c872e/c872e2f13cf94b00f5f3db4cdc6b34abb2c8f449" alt="Post Post"
I have a question about the avoid lefty or avoid righty options. For instance a pitcher like Daniel Cabrera who is dominant against righthanded batters but gets rocked against lefty's, is it wise to use the avoid lefty option. Does the option mean he will pitch around lefty's or will he be removed sooner than if the option were not used. I have used this for relief pitchers but have been hesitant to use it for starters.