Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

Which would be a better combination In Coors:

1.3b-D. Wright
DH-F. Thomas

2.3b-M. Ensberg
DH-F. Thomas

3.3b-M. Ensberg
DH-D. Wright

Respectfully disagree. Go with #1 or #2 and put the extra cash into pitching. You'd be paying too much to DH one of those full-time 3B men and backup isn't an issue since they're both 600 PA guys. Thomas is made for Coors. He's pure OBP and BPHR. When he goes down, you can back him up with one of the many cheap BPHR options out there -- Eldred, Thames, Marrero... Dustin Mohr is nice too, if your regular corner outfielders aren't so great defensively.

Cheap BPHR is the way to win in Coors.

I agree with mark here.

Paying Wright all that cash to DH, is wasting $.

I agree with the last two callers however choice between wright and ensberg depends on how many lefties you will see. 1/3 or more lefties I would go with wright If you will only see righties I would go with Ensberg

Thomas is a tremendous value, especially in coors! Just make sure you get a good back up, as he will miss 50-60 games.... :wink:

I disagree. When in Coors a > result for ballpark single results in a single a whopping 95% of the time but Frank Thomas is one of the few players who does not have any of that on his card on either side and so is a bad fit for Coors. Yes he has maximum # ballpark homer but there are others you can get with maximum # but without the disadvantage of not having any > (not to mention Thomas' injury chance although that's fine since his cost is lowered due to that).

Wright is a 3e25 at 3B which can be quite a liability. I would have no problem playing him at 3B in Coors despite that liability and while at DH he's not quite worth his full cost he'd be fine there depending upon what else you could get. By contrast I would never want a very good defender to play at DH because that's wasting the extra money he costs for being a good defender. For Wright the exception is if your division has very few lefty pitchers as Wright is not optimal in Coors against righties, if you won't be facing many lefties then I'd try to find a different option from Wright.

If we were in US Cellular then I'd be singing a different tune. US Cell has only a 30% chance of single on a > and has a significantly higher HR chance on # (US Cell is 1-18, Coors is 1-15) so Frank Thomas is perfect for US Cell. He's not appropriate for Coors, though, in my view.

Wright is a 3e25 at 3B which can be quite a liability

if that is the case than ramirez must be killing me