Upgrade Mays or Aaron?

[jlt53]

I have enough funds on a 100M Hilltop team that I could upgrade either Mays or Aaron to their most expensive cards.
Which one is the better investment, or should I be spending my money somewhere else altogether?
http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/team/team_other.html?user_id=353053

[andycummings65]

Of the two, I would say upgrade your Willie :D


All Aaron's cards perform offensively..........The cheaper two Mays cards dont do as well

[Hack Wilson]

Maybe true, but I like the high batting average (and high on base) Mays of '55. Does well.

[MtheB]

also depends on ratio of RHP to LHP in your division and league.
The 1955 Mays card does very well against RHP, with a 17.5 HR factor including BP HRs vs RHP.
If you face predominantly RHP, I find that 55 card to be very effective.

[thaibill]

Could never see a reason to pay an extra 2m for fewest RC/700 abs, lowest OBP and lowest win pct of the 3 cards. Can also do without all those double plays.

[jlt53]

Thanks for the input. After going back and forth, I decided the Mays and Aaron I had were good enough and used the money elsewhere.
The nice thing about this game is that the next 162 (or 159, now) games will tell me if I was right or not.