I had a team that has been competing all season - averaging about 4 runs a game
Picked up Jimmy Key for a 7-12 Lonborg (his first bad season for me)
Key has pitched 8 games including one where he gave up 5 runs in 5 innings - his stats are 1.02 whip; 1.86 era and his record is 1-4
He has pitched three 9 inning shutouts and the team scored 8 runs - he had a no decision (11 innings) and a loss 1-0 pitching 9.2 innings.
Meanwhile in another league Ray Sadecki is 1-0-1 with an 11.24 era...
And in one night in two parallel universes, McNally pitches a shut out while his counterpart wins 13-6 in part because McNally hit two homers