All time Greatest Seattle Mariners

[cheeseka1]

Was putting together a team of my hometown ATG Seattle Mariners but cant find Brett Boone, Dan Wilson or Felix Hernandex on the list...WTH?

C = Dan Wilson
1B = Alvin Davis
2B = Brett Boone
3b = Edgar Martinez
SS = A Rod
LF = Jay Buhner (switch from right)
CF = Ken Griffy JR
RF = Ichiro

P1 = Big Unit
P2 = Mark Langston
P3 = Jamie Moyer
P4 = Felix Hernandez

Just for fun--post the ATG from your favorite team.

[LMBombers]

Boston Red Sox

C - Carlton Fisk
1B - Jimmie Foxx
2B - Bobby Doerr
SS - Nomar Garciaparra
3B - Wade Boggs
LF - Jim Rice (or Yaz?)
CF - Tris Speaker
RF - Dwight Evans
DH - Ted Williams

SP - Roger Clemens
SP - Cy Young
SP - Pedro Martinez
SP - Lefty Grove
RP - Dick Radatz

[bontomn]

I'll bite. San Diego Padres I have actually seen play for the Pads, though several had their best years (and cards) elsewhere:

C -- Benito Santiago (Terry Kennedy runner-up)
1B-- Adrian Gonzalez (Willie McCovey, Nate Colbert before my time; Steve Garvey runner-up)
2B -- Mark Loretta (uncarded Bret Boone runner-up)
3B -- Ken Caminiti (Graig Nettles runner-up)
SS -- Ozzie Smith (Garry Templeton runner-up)
RF -- Tony Gwynn (Dave Winfield runner-up
CF -- Steve Finley (Jim Edmonds runner-up)
LF -- Greg Vaughn (Jack Clark runner-up)

SP -- Greg Maddux
SP -- Gaylord Perry
SP -- Randy Jones
SP -- Bruce Hurst
SP -- Dave Dravecky

RP -- Trevor Hoffman
RP -- Mark Davis
RP -- Goose Gossage
RP -- Heath Bell

[JOSEPHKENDALL]

Welcome aboard!

C - Johnny Bench
1B - Joey Votto
2B - Joe Morgan
3B - Pete Rose
SS - Barry Larkin
LF - George Foster
CF - Ken Griffey Jr/Eric Davis
RF - Frank Robinson

SP - Dolf Luque
SP - Paul Derringer
SP - Bucky Walters
SP - Tom Seaver
SP - Noodles Hahn

RP - Rob Dibble
RP - John Franco
RP - Randy Myers

[bontomn]

I'll bite again. Washington Senators (no Nationals!):

C -- Muddy Ruel (Earl Battey runner-up)
1B -- Joe Judge (Mickey Vernon runner-up)
2B -- Bucky Harris (Buddy Myers runner-up)
3B -- Harmon Killebrew (Ossie Bluege runner-up)
SS -- Joe Cronin (Cecil Travis runner-up)
LF -- Frank Howard (Heinie Manush runner-up)
CF -- Tris Speaker (Sam Rice runner-up)
RF -- Goose Goslin (Tony Oliva runner-up)

SP -- Walter Johnson
SP -- Dutch Leonard
SP -- Earl Whitehill
SP -- Alvin Crowder
SP -- Camilo Pascual
SP -- Jim Kaat
SP -- Mudcat Grant

RP -- Firpo Marberry
RP -- Pedro Ramos
RP -- Darold Knowles

Still isn't much of a team! Only ones I've seen live are Battey, Vernon, Killebrew, Howard, Oliva, Pascual. Kaat, Grant, Ramos and Knowles.

[Mr Baseball World]

Milwaukee Brewers and will go with my favorites though maybe not the best(and will have at least one who had limited time/success with the Crew):

C = BJ Surhoff
1B = Prince Fielder
2B = Jim Gantner
3b = Paul Molitor
SS = Robin Yount
LF = Ryan Braun
CF = Gorman Thomas
RF = Hank Aaron

Reserves: Charlie Moore, Cecil Cooper, Rickie Weeks, Jeff Cirillo, Ben Oglivie, Sixto Lezcano, Larry Hisle

P1 = Ted Higuera
P2 = Yovanni Gallardo
P3 = Pete Vuckovich
P4 = Jim Slaton
P5: CC Sabathia

RP: Rollie Fingers
RP: Dan Plesac
RP: John Axford
RP: Pete Ladd
RP: Trevor Hoffman

[Frank Bailey]

Cubs I've seen
c -- Hundley/J. Davis
1b -- Grace
2b -- Sandberg
3b -- Santo
ss -- Banks
lf -- Williams
cf -- A. Phillips/Dernier
rf -- Sosa

sp -- Jenkins
sp -- Sutcliffe
sp -- Holtzman
sp -- Wood
rp -- L. Smith
rp -- Sutter

Cubs' opponents I've seen
c -- Bench
1b -- McCovey
2b -- Morgan
3b -- Mathews/Schmidt
ss -- Tulowitzki/O. Smith
lf -- see rf
cf -- Mays
rf -- Aaron/Clemente/F. Robinson (move one of them to left)

sp -- Gibson
sp -- Drysdale
sp -- Marichal
sp -- Spahn
rp -- Bedrosian
rp -- Sutter

No wonder the Cubs' record hasn't been so good when I've seen them.

[mrharryc]

My all-time Pirates list:

C Manny Sanguillen/ Tony Pena
1B Willie Stargell
2B Bill Mazeroski
SS Honus Wagner
3B Pie Traynor
LF Ralph Kiner
CF Max Carey/Lloyd Waner
RF Roberto Clemente/ Paul Waner

SP Deacon Phillippe
SP Babe Adams
SP Howie Camnitz
SP Wilbur Cooper
SP Doug Drabek

RP Elroy Face
RP Dave Giusti
RP Kent Tekulve

Bonds obviously belongs, but he spent more years in SF. Clemente did play some games in CF, so if I were actually playing a game I'd put him there and insert Dave Parker in RF. In person I've seen Giusti, Tekulve, Drabek, Clemente, Stargell, Sangy, Pena, Maz and Parker. Saw a lot of Pie Traynor, but only doing TV ads for a local heating company on a local wrestling show!

[cheeseka1]

Who would the best ever?
Dang Yankees I suppose?

C= Bill Dickey or Yogi Berra
1B= Lou Gehrig
2B = Joe Gorden
3b = A Rod
SS = Derek Jeter
Lf = Mickey Mantle
CF = Joe Dimaggio
Rf = Babe Ruth
DH = Reggie Jackson

SP = Whitey Ford
SP= Lefty Gomez
SP = Ron Guidry
SP= Roger Clemons

RP = Sparky Lyle
RP = The Sandman Rivera

Manager = Billy Matin? or Casey Stengel?

[LMBombers]

[quote:bc129733b4="Mr. Baseball World"]Milwaukee Brewers and will go with my favorites though maybe not the best(and will have at least one who had limited time/success with the Crew):

C = BJ Surhoff
1B = Prince Fielder
2B = Jim Gantner
3b = Paul Molitor
SS = Robin Yount
LF = Ryan Braun
CF = Gorman Thomas
RF = Hank Aaron

Reserves: Charlie Moore, Cecil Cooper, Rickie Weeks, Jeff Cirillo, Ben Oglivie, Sixto Lezcano, Larry Hisle

P1 = Ted Higuera
P2 = Yovanni Gallardo
P3 = Pete Vuckovich
P4 = Jim Slaton
P5: CC Sabathia

RP: Rollie Fingers
RP: Dan Plesac
RP: John Axford
RP: Pete Ladd
RP: Trevor Hoffman[/quote:bc129733b4]

Hoffman and Aaron were terrible as Brewers. Surhoff over Ted Simmons at C? I guess they were just your favs. Love the 7th inning sausage race!