Possible programming loop hole
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c872e/c872e2f13cf94b00f5f3db4cdc6b34abb2c8f449" alt="Post Post"
Hoyt Wilhelm won a game last night improving his record to 5 and 6. This was correct in the box score and the team was credited with the victory, however on the team stats page Wilhelm was not credited with the victory or even having pitched in the game. The total team victories are correct but when you add up all the pitchers victories they come up one short.
I was the visiting team and Wilhelm came into the game late and tied with runners on base with two outs. He picks the runner off first without officially pitching to a batter, he is pinch hit for in the top of the next inning and my team scored and held on giving Wilhelm the victory, or so it seemed.
I was the visiting team and Wilhelm came into the game late and tied with runners on base with two outs. He picks the runner off first without officially pitching to a batter, he is pinch hit for in the top of the next inning and my team scored and held on giving Wilhelm the victory, or so it seemed.