Which Cobb

[Ruths ruffians]

I read a few threads on which is the better Cobb to use and it is mostly the 1912 version but I was wondering if it is better to use the 1911 version if you are batting him 3rd and looking for more rbi's? I plan on batting him 3rd and I have used this version and seen the difference in rbi production.

Thoughts?

http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/stratomatic/team/team_other.html?user_id=366325

Collins
Bagwell
Cobb
Simmons
Waner
Lindstrom
Munson
Sewell