2(-3) vs 1(0) c ?

[lafayette1]

I need a defensive late inning C for my starter who is poor fielding, but slugs. Which of the above would you choose?

[andycummings65]

the ARMMMMMMMMMM

[WeatherNut]

[quote:72bc822281]the ARMMMMMMMMMM[/quote:72bc822281]

Yep.

WN

[lafayette1]

Thanks...

[Mean Dean]

I wonder. The thing about range is that blocking the plate is a HUGE play. While a SB adds or subtracts fractional runs, blocking the plate puts a two-run swing at stake every time it occurs. My educated guess is that this is a coin flip, and that if there is a call to be made, it's probably actually in favor of the range.

I had studies on this, but I think they were in my old blog and have been eaten by ROWDYROWDYROWDYROWDYROWDYROWDY. I'll try to find them...

[coyote303]

[quote:2ac3abb032="DeanTSC"]I wonder. The thing about range is that blocking the plate is a HUGE play. While a SB adds or subtracts fractional runs, blocking the plate puts a two-run swing at stake every time it occurs. My educated guess is that this is a coin flip, and that if there is a call to be made, it's probably actually in favor of the range.

I had studies on this, but I think they were in my old blog and have been eaten by ROWDYROWDYROWDYROWDYROWDYROWDY. I'll try to find them...[/quote:2ac3abb032]

Interesting. I had considered this a no-brainer in favor of the -3 arm. However, Dean's credentials are the best. I look forward to seeing what his studies say.

[lafayette1]

****,,,I bought the -3.