I'm not critical of the Gwynn pick either. I didn't have much comment because I've never used him. Would've like to in this league.
It's hard to know what kind of cards are best for this league -- the guys with a 3-4 great years and 1-2 bum years or the guys who have 5 consistently good years. Gwynn seems like the latter, as I don't think he has a bad card. I can imagine you can have Tony on your team every year, which can't be said for Brett or Sandberg.