by kenhutchings » Mon Jan 07, 2008 1:00 am
[quote:6daf6ef146="John Law"]24 or 25 man rosters allowed. We are not in a rush to finish by any date. The draft was originally not even going to start until the 14th or something.
After we finish live draft, we must load in order by division! Put your 15 drafted players at the BOTTOM of your draft list.[/quote:6daf6ef146]
It would seem more sensible for me that the 15 drafted players should be at the TOP of the draft list. (15?, I thought it was 16). Let me indicate my concerns by illustrating an example: Say someone drafts Clete Boyer ($2.32 M) for their third baseman, and that George Scott ($2.33 M) is left undrafted. If two teams compete for George Scott in the autodraft, and they have him listed anywhere from 1-10, then one of the teams will get George Scott, and the other team will get Clete Boyer, who is the next highest value 3B, because that team will show him having a higher priority number than the team that drafted him, if drafted players are ranked 11-25.
If we have the drafted players at the TOP of the draft list, then everyone is assured that they'll get their drafted players after the autodraft, and the competition will only be for those players ranked 16-25. If we have the drafted players at the BOTTOM of the draft list, then scenarios such as the example I presented are likely to occur, and then we'll have to shuffle everyone around during the waiver period and before the season starts in order for the drafted players to get on their respective teams.
I participated previously in a 70s league where we had the option of protecting a player from our team for the following league. I wanted to carry over George Brett on my team, who is #2 in ranking for 3B in the 70s game, Mike Schmidt being the highest. We were directed to have our protected players at the bottom of our roster, and I happened to raise the same concern, but was overridden. Well, in a case of SITYS (See, I told you so), two other teams wanted Mike Schmidt, and since Schmidt could only go to one team, the other team ended up with George Brett, who was on my team but was listed as number 25 on my draft list. I wasn't the only one victimized, and I did eventually get Brett on my team, but only after some hassle.
Thus, I would respectfully request that you reconsider your earlier instructions.
:shock: