Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

I imagine many mangers are using favorite players in multiple leagus in 1986 and some of them are good in one league and bad in another.

I was wondering what the biggest performance for a specific players other owners have in multiple leagues. Like >50 point BA and SLG differences.


Here are 2 of mine:
Gary Ward
312/363/367 in 93 games
248/314/311 in 72 games
Mel Hall *
306/337/509 in 93 games
224/276/417 in 72 games
* He is an R7, but in both leagues he has about 90% of AB vrs rightines

Doran has been good and bad .

72 256 39 73 15 1 5 28 37 29 24 10 .285 .376 .410

82 280 33 55 13 2 0 21 34 35 15 5 .196 .283 .257

I have Bobby Welch in several leagues. He has been either excellent or horrible. I guess it is just the nature of chance.

Milte(sorry I didn't post his numbers)

Tommie Herr.
I have him platooning on two teams.
On number 1 he is with Gantner, and playing in Busch.
On number 2, he is with Robby Thompson, and playing in Fenway.

1. 131 AB, 24 R, 4 2b, 13 RBI, .214/.346/.282
2. 188 AB, 33 R, 11 2b, 11 RBI, .325/.405/.404

Is the 59-point differential in OBP enough change for this topic? :shock: :wink:

Here's another: Mike Scioscia.
I have him on two teams.
On number 1, he is platooing with Tim Laudner, and playing in Fenway.
On number 2, he is playing every day in a no cap league in Royals.

1. 285 AB, 32 R, 18 2b, 23 RBI, .274/.363/.354
2. 335 AB, 20 R, 24 2b, 23 RBI, .203/.300/.310

Notice the 71-point differential in batting average.