ATG III Half Squad Keeper Theme Draft & Keeper Trade Thread

[Proverbial Psalms]

Status of Last Call Round...

Ineligible... dacelo, modmark, toyboys, spicki17, roofatoppa3, geekor
Eligible, but PASS... errormagnate, sschu, wjanssen

The following managers may still participate in last call round:

2 - Sykes - Can pick up CHN'84 P, CHA'55 H, CIN'75 P, LA'77 H
3 - giddyup81 - Can pick up CHN'84 P, CHA'55 H, CIN'75 P, LA'77 H
10 - ArrylT - Can pick up LA'77 H

[Sykes25]

I am good to go.

Please send me a PT when I need to enter my team and I will do my best to get in same day.

[ArrylT]

Pass on LA '77 Hitting.

[Proverbial Psalms]

Status of Last Call Round...

Ineligible... dacelo, modmark, toyboys, spicki17, roofatoppa3, geekor
Eligible, but PASS... errormagnate, sschu, wjanssen, sykes, AT

giddyup81 is the last to check in on the last call round:

giddyup81 - Can pick up CHN'84 P, CHA'55 H, CIN'75 P, LA'77 H

[Proverbial Psalms]

AT... can you comment on the rule issue above?

Two managers dropped two hitting teams, whereas the rules state maximum of one hitting and one pitching team allowed per season.

I for one, and several other managers perhaps, would be OK allowing this- that is dropping two same-type half squads instead of max'ing at one of each... thoughts, ruling, etc.???

[giddyup81]

i pass on last call.

[ArrylT]

If an owner replaced 2 hitting squads or 2 pitching half squads then their [b:138f18037d]second[/b:138f18037d] drop is [b:138f18037d]INVALID[/b:138f18037d]. They'll simply have to reclaim the 2nd half-squad they dropped. If another owner has claimed that half-squad then unfortunately they will have to undo their claim as well.

We can discuss changing it in Season IV, but I'm not going re-do the rules midway through a draft, simply because an owner forgot to pay attention to the rules. :)

[ArrylT]

Btw this also invalidates the trade between spicki17 & roofatoppa3, since you cannot acquire via trade a half-squad that was drafted illegally.

My apologies for not catching this sooner, and my thanks to the owner that did.

[ArrylT]

1 - dacelo - DROP '71 Pitt pitching (Intact), PICK UP '57 Milw pitching
2 - Sykes - PASS
3 - giddyup81 - PASS
4 - wjanssen - DROP '55 CIN hitting (Intact), PICK UP '50 Phil hitting
5 - modmark - DROP '90 OAK hitting (Intact), PICK UP '55 CIN hitting
6 - sschu - PASS
7 - toyboys - Drop NYG 34 Hitting (Intact) Pick Up Oak 90 Hitting
8 - steveames - Drop TOR '85 Hitting (intact?), Pick up Wash '24 hitting
9 - spicki17 - drop cle '34 hitting (intact), add pit '09 hitting
10 - ArrylT - SKIP
11 - roofatoppa3 - drp CHN 59 hitting (intact), add NYG 34 hitting
12 - geekor - drop CIN '40 hitting (intact), add CLE '34 hitting

Round 2:
1 - dacelo - Drop DET '84 Hitting (intact), Pick up STL '64 Hitting
2 - Sykes - PASS
3 - giddyup81 - PASS
4 - wjanssen - PASS
5 - modmark - Drop CHN 84 pitching (intact), Pick up CHN 70 Pitching
6 - sschu - PASS
7 - toyboys - Illegal substition
8 - steveames -
9 - spicki17 -
10 - ArrylT - PASS
11 - roofatoppa3 -
12 - geekor -

[spicki17]

AT - i understand that toyboys must pick again, but why does my NYG 34 pitching pick get reset? shouldnt i still receive that claim?