by joethejet » Wed Nov 09, 2011 11:11 pm
[b:0b17e2fda5]Jeep,
Thank you.[/b:0b17e2fda5]
Stoney, Cool stuff thanks for the analysis. Ok, there is that sort of luck but that's not really the type I'm talking about so much. I've played well over 1000 SOM games face-to-face so I see how the dice rolls play out up close and personal. In general, I think teams get the same number of high rolls and low rolls and, as you show, rolls on your card. What is just as critical is the timing of such rolls. This is what I believe leads some teams to have good one run records and others to have poor records. You roll that 1 for a HR in a 10-0 game instead of a 2-1 game, you get the WP with a guy on third and two out instead of a guy at first and two out. This is what I was referencing in my rant, the timing of breaks.
Some players will be inordinately cold for a season. I'm sure your CD play throughs will show you how things can change from season to season. I had Anibal Sanchez have a GREAT year one time and then a more typical year for him the next time (in similar parks). In general you'll see teams with a few guys below where you would expect and a few above and most about what you would think. When you see a team that varies from that negatively, then I would say they've been unlucky and vice versa. What's happening? Well, those particular players could be rolling on the other card more often, or, when on their own card, they could be in the wrong column frequently.
I think my current team is a good example of the latter. Pujols, Hunter, Werth, Wilson, Downs, and Verlander have been awful. (Verlander has been better of late however) On the flip side of that coin, who's been better than expected? Well, only Masset in the pitching I would say. In our hitting, maybe Alvarez due to his power numbers in AT&T although we have two big HR parks in the division and he's got twice as many HRs on the road. SSS but maybe you could say Janish v RHP too. A bunch of hitters are about what you'd think give or take.
Now, what is completely possible to happen is that the guys that suck will pick it up and end up near the numbers you would expect. The problem is that the timing could be such that it won't matter.
The short and long of it is that there are many "luck" factors to consider. When I look at a team to evaluate whether I think they've had good or bad luck, those are the things I look at. So, would you expect all four of my SPs and my two best RPs to be where they are? I would say no, pitching in AT&T. Would you expect my offense to be where it is? Again, I do'nt think you'd expect the big 3 to be so bad, maybe one of them and you'd expect an outlier on the other side too. Of course, going 3-20 without Tulo was hard to believe. If you throw out those games, we're over .500.
As Big M said, however, when it happens several leagues in a row, perhaps I'm missing something.
Jet[/b]