That is an awesome lineup. And the defense (except for Teddy Ballgame) is above-average to excellent, especially up-the-middle where it counts.
I went for more of a defense/OBP with some power arrangement, since I am in the very balanced Shea '86 (9s on all the BP factor rolls):
C -- Yogi
1B -- Mattingly/Hernandez (this is tough b/c they are both 1e6, but Mex was my favorite Met back in '86)
2B -- Doran
SS -- Scooter
3B -- Mr. KFC
LF -- Rajah
CF -- Murphy
RF -- Winfield
DH -- Mattingly/Hernandez
I also went for power pitching: Rocket, The Right Scuff, Ryan and Fernandez. Collectively, they have more Ks than innings pitched. Now I just have to hope the bullpen holds up!