by AeroDave10 » Tue Jan 06, 2009 4:31 pm
[quote:05925f6985="Pjatscfy"]Could I take a 3 instead of a 2?[/quote:05925f6985]
No. Carew can DH ;) I don't see any 1s at 2B for the Twinkies, but there are a couple of 2s. Obviously, one in particular is best, though I think his 2e10 is clearly before it was mandatory for Yankee fans sitting on the first base side to bring their own gloves to the game :lol:
[quote:05925f6985="novie"]If you dont have a "1" at a position, in the essence of this theme... shouldn't you have to select the best rated "2" at that position? [/quote:05925f6985]
Yes and no. If, and only if, you do not have a "1" at a defensive position, you can replace him with a "2". However he doesn't have to be the "best-rated" "2" (i.e. have the fewest errors). This is for two reasons:
(1) The errors are just an approximation. Many players have either more or less errors than expected
(2) It is not my intent to directly force someone to play a particular person. Even majicmg will have at least a few options in the OF ;)