Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

by **Treyomo** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 12:50 pm

OK - well, can you at least give Greenberg a 2e20 rating at SS?

by **mighty moose** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 1:06 pm

[quote:09ec2ae3fe="treyomo"]OK - well, can you at least give Greenberg a 2e20 rating at SS?[/quote:09ec2ae3fe]

Lemme guess, you're gonna put him in Candlestick too ??? :oops:

by **mighty moose** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 1:49 pm

I just sent an e-mail to MrBBW.

by **Mr Baseball World** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 2:33 pm

...will decide shortly. Never pick the 29 Cubs. Where will I leave the holes?

by **mighty moose** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 2:37 pm

Ah, such are the intricacies of this wonderful theme. Position 11 and 12 have their challenges as well. 8)

by **Mr Baseball World** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 2:41 pm

Who needs pitching? Give me the 1920 Indians.

by **mighty moose** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 2:44 pm

1. Frank M - '39 NY Yankees
2. Modmark - '53 Brooklyn Dodgers
3. Denorien - '29 Philadelphia A's
4. MrBBW - '29 Cubs
5. treyomo - '62 Giants
6. GT - '57 Braves (By proxy)
7. DaveHall - '82 Brewers
8. bigmahon - '27 Yankees
9. whoopycat - '06 Cubs
10. bobschwartz22 - '75 Reds
11. rosenthm - '46 Red Sox
12. Moose - '09 Pirates

13. Moose - '80 Expos
14. rosenthm - '19 White Sox
15. bobschwartz22 - '09 Tigers
16. whoopycat - '56 Yankees
17. bigmahon - '15 Phillies
18. DaveHall - '11 Giants
19. GT - '24 Senators (by proxy)
20. treyomo - 40 Tigers
21. MrBBW - [b:ae1dff74e1]'20 Indians[/b:ae1dff74e1]
22. Denorien -
23. Modmark -
24. Frank M -

by **Mr Baseball World** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 2:47 pm

Much easier when you have a team with fewer holes. My first foray at this theme was the same as this version in ATG I. I traded to the #1 spot to get the 53 Dodgers since I figure with them you could put their entire offense out there and be solid offensively and defensively. Then just pitching to get. Holes here at C, 3b, SS and pitching with 1b not great and some CF issues(D vs. O).

Not that the other options don't have holes as well but...........next time.....I love this theme .....thinking it might be good for the 12 league style theme also.

by **rschwartz51** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 4:30 pm

Not in cement, looking for useful guidance from this group.

Basic concept:

$100M
No DH
No Trading or FA's

Separate ATG2 Teams into 3 era's

Each era would makeup a separate division within the league

Each era would have 4 managers within a division and each set would contain 2-3 teams.

Each of the 4 managers draft their teams within the era by sepantine style.

Please add any suggestions.

by **bigmahon** » Thu Feb 23, 2006 4:33 pm

Bob, this idea works well. Bobby has run a series of leagues just like this.

I would do another! :D

Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

Mighty Moose's ATG2 2-team theme chat and draft

IS THERE INTEREST IN THIS COMBO IDEA

Who is online