Bob - you need to use the draft site, not other players, to make proxy picks. We can't do it for you.
Click on the link that says "Create a Proxy". You have the option of leaving a purely sequential list such as:
Varitek pick 1
P Martinez pick 2
A Rodriguez pick 3
OR group the players such as:
Group 1, pick 1 B Roberts,
Group 1, pick 2 L Castillo
Group 1, pick 3 M Ellis
Group 2, pick 1 A Rodriguez
Group 2, pick 2 J Rollins
Group 2, pick 3 C Guillen
Make sure that the option is set to Proxies on "YES" after you set up your list. Please take 5-10 mins & check this out, it's really really important to get to know this in order to have a smooth draft.
Thanks,
Qk