Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

by **Detroit-Tigers** » Sat Jan 27, 2007 8:59 am

[quote:95608cfa5e="7smitty7"]Qk - can you comment on these:

[quote:95608cfa5e]Thanks qk - I really appreciate it. I do have a pitchers park, for HRs anyway - KC - HRs (1-4 both sides) - so I hope he'll be OK. I might as well ask about the guys you didn't comment on: [b:95608cfa5e]Oswalt, Pedro, and R. Hill on the mound; also, can Hawpe play the field, and how does L. Castillo look (and his e rating)[/b:95608cfa5e]. [/quote:95608cfa5e][/quote:95608cfa5e]

Oswalt is decent, 14th best SP, Pedro is in the late 20's with 8 BPHRs vs RH, and 2 vs LH. Hill is usable imo, 31/18 OB, 2/5 BPHRs, but he is way down the list.

Hawpe 4(-3)5, Castillo has great def 2e6

by **Cubit** » Mon Jan 29, 2007 1:21 am

I guess I saw the one game that Cuddyer played in LF! I will be looking for someone to play there this season. I'd appreciate any approaches on my present roster, though I certainly would not mind getting some more in most areas.

by **dlarkins** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 9:17 am

any comments on ldanred's teeamwould be appreciated
i ususally play atg3.

dan

by **Detroit-Tigers** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 10:28 am

A. Soriano - Good hitter's park card, horrible defence
J. Reyes - Good card but low OBP vs RHP (31)
N. Johnson - Great OB and (4,7) BPHRs (he usually has few to none)
A. Rodriguez - 3L Hitter's park card
D. Reyes - 6th best RP
C. Meredith - 15th best RP and R2
E. German - 50+ OB each side, no power, no def, not sure if he will get carded
P. Loduca - decent OB, no power
T. Hoffman - 10th best RP card
E. Hinske - 6R, not sure if he is a vaible starter
D. Oliver - tons of BPHRs (needs to be in pitcher's park)
Jo. Valentin - not the catcher right? Same as Hinske
G. Maddux - decent SP card, few BPHRs
C. Bradford - mid tier reliever with 0 BPHRs

by **AFDickie** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 11:11 am

What do you think of my picks? I think I had a couple miscues...and a couple good picks besides the obvious ones. Thanks.

by **Detroit-Tigers** » Tue Jan 30, 2007 1:22 pm

L. Berkman - 4th best card vs RHP
I. Suzuki - great pitcher's park lead-off/2nd type guy (although only 38 OB vs RHP)
M. Holliday - Good power hitter's park guy
O. Vizquel - 1e4
G. Matthews - pitcher's park CF
S. Kazmir - 11nd best SP card
R. Zimmerman - decent hitter, with 1 def
F. Thomas - top 10 hitter
J. Francis -12th best SP and *SP
J. Carroll - good OB, great def, no power
J. Jennings - top 20 SP and *SP
B. Sheets - top 30 SP
J. Kendall - decent OB
K. Rogers - top 50 SP

by **qksilver69** » Wed Jan 31, 2007 7:31 pm

a few takes of my own....

E German should get a card, he played nearly half a season & is not a batting title threat, so unlikely to skew season results, which is TSN's main criteria for exclusion. His 3e8 card at 2b is very playable IMO & I like the pick a lot on that basis.

Hinske not great D but viable corner IF in a platoon. His 6R card has enough pop to hit in the 6/7 hole on a good-hitting team.

Jo Valentin - same comment. Has a lot of SLG & hits vs RHP, little OPB so best for 6th slot. Given position scarcity at 2b very viable in a platoon role.

by **blsmith7** » Sun Mar 04, 2007 2:05 pm

Bump - since we all took February off, maybe we can pick up the chatter. Be great if we could get it going this week. Let's go Bernie!!!

by **Cubit** » Tue Mar 06, 2007 9:51 pm

Ready to go, or at least hoping I am. Looking for lots!

by **AFDickie** » Fri Mar 09, 2007 6:35 pm

commish?

Archive of SportingNews.com's old SOM Baseball forum

2007 pre-card live draft

any comments on my team

Hey DT

when is this one kicking off?

Who is online