Quiz Humphreys Goose or Beggs

[Fast Freddie 69]

Playing at FW '46 . Division is Baker , Dodgers '77 , Yanks '56 . 6 pitchers parks . Quiz Humphreys Goose and Beggs are out there . Which would you grab ? Thanks in advance.

[Play By The Rules]

Goose if you have a decent compliment of LH or reverse RH relievers, otherwise Humphries.

[Fast Freddie 69]

Lefferts , Dayley , Bahnsen , Watt . Humphreys is who I have and 690K . So I figured I'd ask .

[GREGKOESTER]

I've never used Goose. I like my relievers more towards even. Beggs would be my first choice, then Humphreys. I've just had pretty good luck with Beggs.

[aceventura55369]

With all of those HR parks I would go with Beggs or Quiz

[Treyomo]

Quiz all day...

[Play By The Rules]

Gossage is your best choice.

[GREGKOESTER]

PBTR. If you use Gosssage, do you pick a guy like maybe Merritt from the left? Or doesn't it matter? I take it then the third guy would be an E or a 1L or 1R.

[Play By The Rules]

Well, I certainly have had Gossage blow up on me. On one team I had to keep him because there weren't any alternative and he finished with a 7+ ERA...

Bahnsen holds his own vs. LH batter, he has Lefferts, who I'm no great fan of in his park but is leftycentric... The times I've had problems with Gossage is in hitters setups where lefties kill him the worst.

The problem I have with Beggs and Quiz is their high WHIPs, I do like their lack of #s and they seem to overperform their cards in hitters park setups.

[Play By The Rules]

Yeah, I'd probably think about trading in Watt for Merritt or even Shoffner. Forgot to say that Dayley sucks against LH and is not that great a fit here.