the BPHRs don't matter as long as their natural card ability to produce HRs is high, do you have the ratings disk?
looking at my disk, these are listed as the top 20 pure HR hitters from the left and right side (the percentage is for their card only, but it is still a good metric to compare by):
the numbers listed are the "chances" on the card, and the percentage (chances/108 * 100)
[u:f7edd072dc]from the rightside[/u:f7edd072dc]
[code:1:f7edd072dc]
Bonds, B* 17.7 16.39%
Sexson,R 12.8 11.85%
Beltre,A 11 10.19%
Glaus,T 10.3 9.54%
Edmonds,J* 9.9 9.17%
Cota,H 9.8 9.07%
Morneau,J* 9.1 8.43%
Ortiz,D* 9.1 8.43%
Dunn,A* 9 8.33%
Pujols,A 8.8 8.15%
Thome,J* 8.8 8.15%
Stinnett,K 8.6 7.96%
Pickering,C* 8.1 7.50%
Ramirez,M 8 7.41%
Delgado,C* 7.6 7.04%
Mauer,J* 7.6 7.04%
Sosa,S 7.6 7.04%
Walker,L* 7.6 7.04%
Hafner,T* 7.5 6.94%
Clark,T+ 7.4 6.85%
Griffey Jr,K* 6.9 6.39%
Branyan,R* 6.8 6.30%
Rolen,S 6.8 6.30%
Sierra,R+ 6.8 6.30%
[/code:1:f7edd072dc]
[u:f7edd072dc]from the leftside[/u:f7edd072dc]
[code:1:f7edd072dc]
Rodriguez,A 12 11.11%
Pena,W 11.9 11.02%
Guerrero,V 11.8 10.93%
Lowell,M 9.8 9.07%
Hernandez,J 9.8 9.07%
Ojeda,M 9.6 8.89%
Batista,T 9.2 8.52%
Grissom,M 9.1 8.43%
Bay,J 9 8.33%
Mirabelli,D 8.9 8.24%
Werth,J 8.6 7.96%
Glaus,T 8.5 7.87%
Saenz,O 8.4 7.78%
Phelps,J 8.4 7.78%
Pujols,A 8.3 7.69%
Ramirez,M 7.8 7.22%
Leone,J 7.6 7.04%
Thames,M 7.6 7.04%
Jones,C+ 7.4 6.85%
Jacobsen,B 7.2 6.67%
Hernandez,R 7.1 6.57%
[/code:1:f7edd072dc]
looking at that list glaus is a good choice (that's not considering his injury, just pure HR numbers)