by mbrake » Wed Jun 25, 2008 5:55 pm
[quote:92771c8916="2cityfan"]mbrake wrote:
[/quote:92771c8916]
[quote:92771c8916]All players belong to their base card team exclusively. In this particualr case, (since the Braves & Dodgers are both in the league and thus are considered base teams), then A. Jones is a base player for the Braves and R. Furcal is a base player for the Dodgers. They can only exclusively play for their base team the entire year. They are off limts to [b:92771c8916]ALL [/b:92771c8916]other teams by any means of acquisition (e.g. ineligible via draft, waivers, free-agency or trades) throughout the entire season. They are the sole property of their respective base team.[/[/quote:92771c8916]quote]
mbrake, I like the concept behind this league, so thanks for starting it. But I think managers should be allowed to trade base players providing the traded players count toward the supplemental limit, and the base players played/or are on the team they are going to. I am not against the challenge of building a roster with only a limited pool of players to pick from. Believe me the White Sox have plenty of challenges even with 10 supplemental spots. But I think allowing this trading would add to the strategy and roster building challenge of the league without violating the spirit of the "reality bites" theme. Without allowing this type of trading, trading is truly not allowed for all practical purposes..
What are your thoughts mbrake?[/quote]
If I allow trades involving base players that circumvents the whole strategy. As the owner of the Red Sox, I am facing the most stringent transaction restrictions with only one supplemental player being availble to me at any given time. The true intent of the league is to see if you can manage the "real" team's roster with their respective limited resources, warts and weaknesses. The supplemental players are only a tool to put teams on the same playing field salary-wise. If it's wide open free wheeling and dealing you like to see, then this league will disappoint you in that regard. If you want to see if you could do a better job with the White Sox than Ozzie Guillen and Kenny Williams, then this is for you.