ATG IV 16 event Franchise League

[buster j ratt]

I am for the play a benchwarmer in as many games as illegal player $$$ penalties I don;t like because I run to many teams Some already have to have $$$$ available Much too easy to pull boner again but if I have a name I can't play easier too remember That's my 2 cents worth and NO I don't use punctuation and when I do it is usually wrong? :roll:

[jpgavin]

So far the opinions look like this:

buster j ratt - play a scrub
Idanred
ndycummings
majicmg - play a scrub and monetary penalty
rosenthm
FAaron - play a scrub
AeroDave - monetary penalty
Pjatscfy - play a scrub
jpgavin - play a scrub
novie
Cubs48
2cityfan

It looks like we are leaning toward a rule that requires a manager who uses an ineligible player to start a back up (scrub) for the same number of games that the ineligible player was used. I like majicmg's idea of a graduated penalty (more severe for second and third offenses).

We still have the weekend before season 2 starts. Other opinions or suggestions?

[AeroDave10]

We could hold each other responsible for checking the other teams in our division. If everybody's rosters are up to snuff before the season starts, then picking up ineligible guys during the season should be very easy to track.

[Cubs48]

So far the opinions look like this:

buster j ratt - play a scrub
Idanred
ndycummings
majicmg - play a scrub and monetary penalty
rosenthm
FAaron - play a scrub
AeroDave - monetary penalty
Pjatscfy - play a scrub
jpgavin - play a scrub
novie
Cubs48 - play scrub (any offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
2cityfan -

It looks like we are leaning toward a rule that requires a manager who uses an ineligible player to start a back up (scrub) for the same number of games that the ineligible player was used. I like majicmg's idea of a graduated penalty (more severe for second and third offenses).

We still have the weekend before season 2 starts. Other opinions or suggestions?

[jpgavin]

OK, let's make this the vote. The combination of playing a scrub and monetary penalties starting with the second offense (per season) will work as outlined by majicmg above.

buster j ratt - play a scrub
Idanred
ndycummings
majicmg - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
rosenthm
FAaron - play a scrub
AeroDave - monetary penalty
Pjatscfy - play a scrub
jpgavin - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
novie
Cubs48 - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
2cityfan -

So, we have 3 for the combined penalty, 3 for playing a scrub only, and one for monetary penalty only. Since more than half the managers have voted, we'll use whatever rule is leading at 10pm tomorrow. If no one else votes, we'll have AeroDave pick between the two tied options (since he was the only other manager to cast a vote).

[rosenthm]

OK, let's make this the vote. The combination of playing a scrub and monetary penalties starting with the second offense (per season) will work as outlined by majicmg above.

buster j ratt - play a scrub
Idanred
ndycummings
majicmg - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
rosenthm - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
FAaron - play a scrub
AeroDave - monetary penalty
Pjatscfy - play a scrub
jpgavin - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
novie
Cubs48 - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
2cityfan -

So, we have 3 for the combined penalty, 3 for playing a scrub only, and one for monetary penalty only. Since more than half the managers have voted, we'll use whatever rule is leading at 10pm tomorrow. If no one else votes, we'll have AeroDave pick between the two tied options (since he was the only other manager to cast a vote).

[AeroDave10]

I'll pick the combined one.

[jpgavin]

ok, that makes it 5-3

[2cityfan]

buster j ratt - play a scrub
Idanred
andycummings
majicmg - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
rosenthm - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
FAaron - play a scrub
AeroDave - monetary penalty
Pjatscfy - play a scrub
jpgavin - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
novie
Cubs48 - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
2cityfan - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)

[andycummings65]

buster j ratt - play a scrub
Idanred
andycummings play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
majicmg - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
rosenthm - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
FAaron - play a scrub
AeroDave - monetary penalty
Pjatscfy - play a scrub
jpgavin - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
novie
Cubs48 - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)
2cityfan - play scrub (each offense) add monetary penalty for 2nd and subsequent offenses (graduated)