We'll use the same scoring system as Barnstormers for the rankings here. One point for each regular season win, five points for making the playoffs, five points for making the finals, and ten points for a championship.
Managers Rankings (Total points)
1. andycummings - 468 (3 playoffs, 3 finals, 1 championship)
2. 2cityfan - 464 (3 playoffs)
3. Cubs48 - 439 (2 playoffs, 1 final, 1 championship)
4. Pjatscfy - 438 (2 playoffs, 1 final, 1 championship)
5. AeroDave - 431 (1 playoff, 1 final, 1 championship)
6. novie - 427 (2 playoffs, 1 final, 1 championship)
6. Idanred - 427 (2 playoffs)
8. FAaron - 414 (1 playoff, 1 final)
9. jpgavin - 398 (1 playoff, 1 final)
10. buster j ratt - 395 (1 playoff, 1 final)
11. majicmg - 390 (1 playoff)
12. rosenthm - 369 (1 playoff)
Franchise Rankings (Average points)
1. Yankees - 101 (1 season, 1 playoff)
2. Pirates - 96.75 (4 seasons, 3 playoffs, 2 finals, 1 championship)
3. Giants - 95.8 (5 seasons, 4 playoffs, 2 finals, 1 championship)
4. Red Sox - 86.5 (2 seasons, 1 playoff, 1 final)
5. Phillies - 85 (5 seasons, 1 playoff, 1 final)
6. White Sox - 84.2 (5 seasons, 2 playoffs, 1 final, 1 championship)
7. Indians - 83 (5 seasons, 1 playoff, 1 final, 1 championship)
7. Braves - 83 (5 seasons, 2 playoffs)
7. Dodgers - 83 (3 seasons, 1 playoff, 1 final)
10. Tigers - 81.25 (4 seasons, 1 playoff)
11. Cubs - 81.2 (5 seasons, 1 playoff)
12. Reds - 80.8 (5 seasons, 1 playoff, 1 final, 1 championship)
13. Twins - 80.67 (3 seasons)
14. Cardinals - 80.5 (2 seasons)
15. Orioles - 76.6 (5 seasons, 1 playoff)
16. A's - 74 (1 season)