Well, we need our commish, Steven, to set us on a path. Seems we all want to use the ATG 5 set, but that is where agreement diverges. Some want the NeL players in the game as a separate available team, some don't. Some want to increase the cap to $140m, some don't. I'm hoping these issues aren't deal breakers for anyone. OK, let's vote and go the democratic route, with our Commish having the final deciding vote/say, if needed. I've put the votes in for those who expressed their opinions in earlier posts.
VOTE (Total so far = 6 Y & 5 N for NeL franchise/3 Y & 7 N for raising the cap).
NeL players as a separate franchise, Y, or don't use NeL players, N?
Raise the cap to $140m, Y, or keep the cap the same ($125m), N?
Modmark - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
errormagnate - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
andycummings - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Warrenbob - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Cubs48 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
CATom - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
bontomn - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
FrankM - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
DonFESQ - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Sdajr76 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
Jawajedi - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
JCHansen - ?
$125 million ATG v.IV Franchise League (private) Season 2
by modmark46 » Sat Dec 26, 2009 5:50 pm
Well, we need our commish, Steven, to set us on a path. Seems we all want to use the ATG 5 set, but that is where agreement diverges. Some want the NeL players in the game as a separate available team, some don't. Some want to increase the cap to $140m, some don't. I'm hoping these issues aren't deal breakers for anyone. OK, let's vote and go the democratic route, with our Commish having the final deciding vote/say, if needed. I've put the votes in for those who expressed their opinions in earlier posts.
VOTE (Total so far = 6 Y & 5 N for NeL franchise/4 Y & 7 N for raising the cap).
NeL players as a separate franchise, Y, or don't use NeL players, N?
Raise the cap to $140m, Y, or keep the cap the same ($125m), N?
Modmark - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
errormagnate - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
andycummings - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Warrenbob - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Cubs48 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
CATom - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
bontomn - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
FrankM - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
DonFESQ - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Sdajr76 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
Jawajedi - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
JCHansen - ?
VOTE (Total so far = 6 Y & 5 N for NeL franchise/4 Y & 7 N for raising the cap).
NeL players as a separate franchise, Y, or don't use NeL players, N?
Raise the cap to $140m, Y, or keep the cap the same ($125m), N?
Modmark - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
errormagnate - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
andycummings - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Warrenbob - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Cubs48 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
CATom - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
bontomn - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
FrankM - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
DonFESQ - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Sdajr76 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
Jawajedi - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
JCHansen - ?
- modmark46
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
by errormagnate » Sun Dec 27, 2009 3:09 pm
Just to be clear despite voting NO on all of these changes I am playing and committed to the entire 12 seasons regardless so no worries from my end about 'deal-breakers' just tell me where to sign them up and I'm good to go.
- errormagnate
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
by JCHansen » Mon Dec 28, 2009 10:16 am
Modmark - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
errormagnate - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
andycummings - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Warrenbob - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Cubs48 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
CATom - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
bontomn - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
FrankM - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
DonFESQ - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Sdajr76 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
Jawajedi - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
JCHansen - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
errormagnate - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
andycummings - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Warrenbob - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Cubs48 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
CATom - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
bontomn - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
FrankM - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
DonFESQ - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Sdajr76 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
Jawajedi - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
JCHansen - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
- JCHansen
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
by modmark46 » Mon Dec 28, 2009 11:23 am
Final Vote Tally =
7 For & 5 Against for adding a NeL Franchise.
8 Against & 4 For raising the Cap.
So democracy has spoken. The cap remains at $125m, while we add the NeL as a franchise. In re: to the NeL Franchise, these were my thoughts for it's RPs only and bench player issues, that I posted a few days ago. Steven should have final say about this, of course.
[quote:9fe60d6e8a]I think the NeL mgr. should be allowed to draft any RP (only) guys, under $2m, that aren't on someone else's roster, and also draft bench guys under $1m that aren't part of a drafted roster. To keep in the spirit of the NeL franchise, you should try and draft minority (black & hispanic) RPs and Bench guys, if at all possible. Of course, you would have to choose a NeL ball park.[/quote:9fe60d6e8a]
Modmark - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
errormagnate - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
andycummings - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Warrenbob - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Cubs48 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
CATom - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
bontomn - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
FrankM - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
DonFESQ - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Sdajr76 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
Jawajedi - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
JCHansen - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
7 For & 5 Against for adding a NeL Franchise.
8 Against & 4 For raising the Cap.
So democracy has spoken. The cap remains at $125m, while we add the NeL as a franchise. In re: to the NeL Franchise, these were my thoughts for it's RPs only and bench player issues, that I posted a few days ago. Steven should have final say about this, of course.
[quote:9fe60d6e8a]I think the NeL mgr. should be allowed to draft any RP (only) guys, under $2m, that aren't on someone else's roster, and also draft bench guys under $1m that aren't part of a drafted roster. To keep in the spirit of the NeL franchise, you should try and draft minority (black & hispanic) RPs and Bench guys, if at all possible. Of course, you would have to choose a NeL ball park.[/quote:9fe60d6e8a]
Modmark - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
errormagnate - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
andycummings - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Warrenbob - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Cubs48 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
CATom - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
bontomn - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
FrankM - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
DonFESQ - N (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
Sdajr76 - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
Jawajedi - Y (NeL franchise), Y (don't raise the cap)
JCHansen - Y (NeL franchise), N (don't raise the cap)
- modmark46
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
OK, let's resume the draft!
by modmark46 » Mon Dec 28, 2009 11:37 am
[i:2b6d6ad552]I suppose those who have already drafted should have the option of changing their selection, given the changes that have just occurred. I am staying with my original pick.
[/i:2b6d6ad552]
Available Franchises (please delete when you take the franchise) -
ATL/MIL-POST/MIL-EXP/BSB:
BAL/SLB:
BRN/LA:
CHC:
CIN/CLE:
CWS:
DET:
NeL:
PHI:
PIT:
STL:
WAS/MIN/TEX:
SEA/TOR/CAL/SD/HOU/MON:
Season 2 Franchise selection order:
1. Modmark - NYG/SF (I am keeping this pick)
2. sdajr76 - NYY/NYM
3. DonFESQ - PHA/KC-Post/KC-exp/OAK:
4. andycummings - BOS
5. jawajedi
6. Bontomn
7. errormagnate
8. JCHansen
9. Warrenbob
10. CATom
11. FrankM
12. Cubs48
[/i:2b6d6ad552]
Available Franchises (please delete when you take the franchise) -
ATL/MIL-POST/MIL-EXP/BSB:
BAL/SLB:
BRN/LA:
CHC:
CIN/CLE:
CWS:
DET:
NeL:
PHI:
PIT:
STL:
WAS/MIN/TEX:
SEA/TOR/CAL/SD/HOU/MON:
Season 2 Franchise selection order:
1. Modmark - NYG/SF (I am keeping this pick)
2. sdajr76 - NYY/NYM
3. DonFESQ - PHA/KC-Post/KC-exp/OAK:
4. andycummings - BOS
5. jawajedi
6. Bontomn
7. errormagnate
8. JCHansen
9. Warrenbob
10. CATom
11. FrankM
12. Cubs48
- modmark46
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
by errormagnate » Mon Dec 28, 2009 12:15 pm
Public Proxy since I am not sure how often I can check the internet this week - on a brief 'deployment'.
1.ChC
2.NeL
3.PHI
1.ChC
2.NeL
3.PHI
- errormagnate
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
by sdajr76 » Mon Dec 28, 2009 12:25 pm
i hope everyone had wonderful holidays with their families.
We have decided to switch the card set to ATG V and add the NeL as a franchise. Players that are carded to more than one franchise will be available to ALL the franchises that cards are available for. The players will be competed for via the draft. If neither franchise selects the player, the player will remain an available free agent for both franchises throughout the season. If one franchise drops the player the player is available to ALL carded franchises.
i think the only thing to figure out now is how we are going to makes RP's available for the NeL franchise to use? Ideas and suggestions welcomed.
We will restart the draft order. Okay, let's pick our franchises.
125 million cap for your roster (use 140 mil cap limit), 12 season theme league, you can only
chose a franchise once, rotating franchise selection based off of sign up
order, Advanced, DH league and weighted drops. Pick a franchise and only use players carded to that franchise.
Franchises and Grouping are as follows:
ATL/MIL-POST/MIL-EXP/BSB:
BAL/SLB:
BOS:
BRN/LA:
CHC:
CIN/CLE:
CWS:
DET:
NeL:
NYG/SF:
NYY/NYM:
PHA/KC-Post/KC-exp/OAK:
PHI:
PIT:
STL:
WAS/MIN/TEX:
SEA/TOR/CAL/SD/HOU/MON:
Season 2 Franchise selection order is as follows:
1. Modmark - NYG/SF
2. sdajr76 - NeL
3. DonFESQ -
4. andycummings -
5. jawajedi -
6. Bontomn -
7. errormagnate -
8. JCHansen -
9. CATom -
10. Warrenbob -
11. FrankM -
12. Cubs48 -
The Season One Franchise draft order and selection results were:
1. sdajr76 (CHC)
2. donFESQ (NYY/NYM)
3. andycummings (NYG/SF)
4. jawajedi (STL)
5. bontomn (PHA/KC/OAK)
6. errormagnate (PIT)
7. jchansen (BOS)
8. CATom (BRN/LA)
9. warrenbob (DET)
10. Frank M (ATL/MIL/BSB)
11. Cubs48 (CIN/CLE)
12. modmark (PHI)
-steven
We have decided to switch the card set to ATG V and add the NeL as a franchise. Players that are carded to more than one franchise will be available to ALL the franchises that cards are available for. The players will be competed for via the draft. If neither franchise selects the player, the player will remain an available free agent for both franchises throughout the season. If one franchise drops the player the player is available to ALL carded franchises.
i think the only thing to figure out now is how we are going to makes RP's available for the NeL franchise to use? Ideas and suggestions welcomed.
We will restart the draft order. Okay, let's pick our franchises.
125 million cap for your roster (use 140 mil cap limit), 12 season theme league, you can only
chose a franchise once, rotating franchise selection based off of sign up
order, Advanced, DH league and weighted drops. Pick a franchise and only use players carded to that franchise.
Franchises and Grouping are as follows:
ATL/MIL-POST/MIL-EXP/BSB:
BAL/SLB:
BOS:
BRN/LA:
CHC:
CIN/CLE:
CWS:
DET:
NeL:
NYG/SF:
NYY/NYM:
PHA/KC-Post/KC-exp/OAK:
PHI:
PIT:
STL:
WAS/MIN/TEX:
SEA/TOR/CAL/SD/HOU/MON:
Season 2 Franchise selection order is as follows:
1. Modmark - NYG/SF
2. sdajr76 - NeL
3. DonFESQ -
4. andycummings -
5. jawajedi -
6. Bontomn -
7. errormagnate -
8. JCHansen -
9. CATom -
10. Warrenbob -
11. FrankM -
12. Cubs48 -
The Season One Franchise draft order and selection results were:
1. sdajr76 (CHC)
2. donFESQ (NYY/NYM)
3. andycummings (NYG/SF)
4. jawajedi (STL)
5. bontomn (PHA/KC/OAK)
6. errormagnate (PIT)
7. jchansen (BOS)
8. CATom (BRN/LA)
9. warrenbob (DET)
10. Frank M (ATL/MIL/BSB)
11. Cubs48 (CIN/CLE)
12. modmark (PHI)
-steven
- sdajr76
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
by sdajr76 » Mon Dec 28, 2009 12:51 pm
[quote:af22df13f3]I think the NeL mgr. should be allowed to draft any RP (only) guys, under $2m, that aren't on someone else's roster, and also draft bench guys under $1m that aren't part of a drafted roster. To keep in the spirit of the NeL franchise, you should try and draft minority (black & hispanic) RPs and Bench guys, if at all possible. Of course, you would have to choose a NeL ball park.[/quote:af22df13f3]
sounds good to me.
-steven
sounds good to me.
-steven
- sdajr76
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Tue Jul 03, 2012 2:34 pm
Return to Individual League Chat
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests