3B: Boyer vs Bando

[TRW]

I have both Boyer & Bando. Looking to trade 1 of them. Who is the better fit for my team? (Playing in Oakland 90.)

http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/baseball/stratomatic/atg2/team/team_other.html?user_id=108899

[gamiam]

They are similar types, so I can't see where the stadium or line-up would matter very much. IMO, Bando is FAR better than Boyer.

[The Last Druid]

I have higher expectations for Bando, which in the handful of times that I've used him, have never been met. Boyer I don't expect much from and have been satisfied with the performances I have had from him. I tend to bat him 6th or 7th, primarily on homerun friendly teams. Given the price difference I will pretty much always take Boyer over Bando, but am not that fond of either ATG II player.

[BassballJG]

Boyer's 1 is nice, and if Bando is not available, I use him. But unless you need the money, stick with Sal.

[TomP]

I'd keep Bando. Boyer's card is design for a HR park. His offense will suffer in Oakland.

[danielz]

80 teams, I've used Boyer once.
In Briggs which is homer friendly.
611 atbats
.249 avg
31 DO
23 HR
87 RBI

I've never used Bando

[Houndog]

I have seen Bando consistently put good numbers in the leagues I have been involved in. Boyer has been hit or miss from what I have observed. In a small-ball park Boyer suffers the most. Boyer is a 1 and Bando is a 2 fielding. At third base I place less emphasis on fielding. Both are injury free and Boyer costs less. I think it depends on your park.

[MICHAELTARBELL]

I don't think either player is a particularly good choice in a pitchers park.

I have used bando several times, always in hitters parks, and he fluctuates between very good and outstanding!

Have never used Boyer....