by l.strether » Sun Apr 24, 2011 2:55 pm
I think, for the most part, this is a solid team, which (like most teams) has its flaws.
As to your starting staff, I think Lester is an excellent ace card, and I think Gonzalez and Carmona are solid under 4 * starters, but I think Santana gives up too much power against lefty hitters.
In your bullpen, I think Rivera is a great card but overpriced, considering solid and cheaper closers like Marmol, Bailey, and Rodriguez are usually available. Same goes for Hensley who is an excellent setup guy but a little pricey when cheaper but not much worse options like Sanches, Ramirez and Casilla can be had.
As to your lineup: You did an excellent job getting both Pujols and Fielder as the center of your lineup. I think Cervelli and Pierzynski are both excellent offensive deals..although you have to be cool with their defensive drawbacks. I'm not crazy about Rhymes' and YOung's defense, although Young is a solid offensive deal for the price...and I really like Reyes.
I also really like your outfielders, and Gomez is a particularly good deal with his offense, defense, and speed at a very low price. However, for Chase field, I would prefer a little more pop. Also considering the money invested in them..you just have too many outfielders.
Anyway, this is a solid team that takes a sound approach to its organization, even if its not exactly the approach I would take.
Good luck on what should be a successful season.