1. Terry101- Alex Gordon- LF, KC
2. Mr. BaseballWorld - Kyle Lohse SP STL (via proxy)
3. manleeman - Casey Kotchman - 1B TB
4. bbasebrawl - Justin Turner, 2b, NYM
5. pirhala - Josh Tomlin SP CLE (via proxy)
6. nythawk-Allen Craig OF/2B STL
7. Jerlins - Sergio Santos RP Chi (AL)
8. 7smitty7 - Todd Helton 1B COL
9. ironwill1 - Charlie Morton SP Pit
10. Palmtana - Phillip Humber SP CHW
11. thisisdan26 - Donnie Murphy 3B FLA
12. thisisdan26 - Fernando Salas RP STL
{{SUPP. DRAFT ROUND 2}}
13. Terry101- David Robertson, RP, NYY
14. Mr. BaseballWorld - Zach Duke SP ARI
15. manleeman- Greg Dobbs, 3b, fla
16. bbasebrawl- Jack Cust, Dh, Sea
17. pirhala - David Pauley, RP, Sea
18. nythawk-Travis Hafner DH CLE
19. Jerlins-Mark Melanson(proxy)
20. 7smitty7
21. ironwill1
22. Palmtana
23. tcochran
24. thisisdan26