Ok with a little creativity I was able to recreate the 1989 Giants line up:
C- T. Kennedy 1984
1B- W. Clark 1989
2B- R. Thompson 1989
3B- M. Williams 1990
SS- J. Uribe 1986
LF- K. Mitchell 1989
CF- B. Butler 1993
RF- (No Candyman in the set, so using 1986 C. Davis as a stand in)
On the pitching side its not quite as clean, but here is a good attempt:
R. Reuschel 1973
D. Dravecky 1983
J. Montefusco 1978
M. Krukow 1983
J. Burkett 1990
Bullpen
S. Garrelts 1987
C. Lefferts 1984
So for the rotation I had to get a bit creative, since Garrelts doesn't have a starter card and the others aren't in ATG. However, most of the players used were on the roster or around that time frame so close enough.
I will fill in the roster with other Giants and players from this period to round things out for a $60 million no DH cap league.
If anyone is interested in doing a similar team and joining a theme along these lines, post the roster and come join.
League: MLB team theme
PW: baseball