by Mean Dean » Thu Sep 22, 2011 7:49 pm
Hines is a member of Baseball Think Factory's Hall of Merit, which I consider to be an honor worthy of more respect than the Hall of Fame, although obviously not one that will make you as famous ;) The Hall of Merit was a committee of around 50 baseball historians, whose voting system was far more transparent and logical than the Hall of Fame's.
Hines actually is a charter member of the Hall of Merit, although that doesn't mean quite the same thing as it did in the Hall of Fame. The Hall of Merit began voting in "year" 1898, with a ballot including anyone who retired before 1893. Hines, Deacon White, George Gore and Ross Barnes were the players elected from that ballot.
His [url=http://www.baseballthinkfactory.org/files/hall_of_merit/discussion/the_hall_of_merit_plaque_room1/]"plaque"[/url] reads:[quote:836e7cbf5c]The first man to win the triple crown, Hines played exceptionally well offensively and defensively for a very long time. The first National Leaguer to win back-to-back batting titles (1878-79), the right-handed slugger hit .302 (11 seasons over .300) with an OPS+ of 131. Hines also earned 419 WS in 14.7 non-NA seasons, including 181 from 1878-82. An outstanding defensive player noted for his range and spectacular running catches (he led his leagues once in double plays and fielding percentage twice), he’s credited with the first unassisted triple play in a game in 1878. Retired with the ML career records for OF games (1,376), CF games (1,303), and double plays (56). Key member of three pennant winners (1876, 79 and the World Champions of 1884); also with the Providence teams that were runner-ups to the great Chicago squad (1880-82). NL Triple Crown (1878). STATS, Inc. NL MVP (1878). Five-time STATS, Inc. NL Outfielder (1876, 1878-79, 1882, 1884). Three-time Win Shares NL Silver Slugger Award (1878-79, 1884). Seven-time Win Shares NL Gold Glove Award winner (1876, 1879-84). Career OWP (.663). NL leader in SLG (1878), 2B (1876, 1881, 1884), OPS (1878), Games (1879), AB (1879), Hits (1879), TB (1878-79), HR (1878), RBI (1878), Singles (1879), AB/HR (1878), and Times on Base (1879).[/quote:836e7cbf5c]