Joe, thanks for the response. You have had some bad luck early with Tulo, there is no doubt. But that's the risk you take with him. Same with Utley, who has been healthy so far. But the inevitable will come for me too! :lol:
I think you are not connecting some of the dots with your team though. Your SP's are giving up more earned runs than they should because the base runners they are allowing are a) staying on the bases and b) advancing to the next base at an alarming rate. Is the OSB % an anomaly? Maybe. But HAL has attempted to steal against you 69 times so far, and you've only managed to gun down 7 of them. So I bet he'll keep trying.
You're also missing (ignoring? 8-) ) my main point, which is that whatever system you are using to evaluate cards appears to be flawed, especially in this card set. At some point you have to accept that there is more than bad luck involved here.