Paging PKBlack Enter your team - Theme League - ERA vs. ERA!

[honestiago1]

1) 1800's-1910
2) 1911-1919
3) 1920-1929
4) 1930-1939
5) 1940-1949
6) 1950-1959
7) 1960-1969 - johnnyblazers
8) 1970-1979
9) 1980-1989--honestiago
10) 1990-present
11) Negro Leagues-I
12) Negro Leagues II

[honestiago1]

Does this mean I HAVE to use Royals Stadium '80, since it is the only park listed for the 80s?

[honestiago1]

Most of the '78 parks were still in use in the 80s. How about we say the park has to actually be in use during the decade? Because I think there's a lot of decades without parks, and constraining managers to one park choice gives other managers an unfair advantage.

[JohnnyBlazers]

[quote:2278c908d9="honestiago"]Does this mean I HAVE to use Royals Stadium '80, since it is the only park listed for the 80s?[/quote:2278c908d9]

I guess we'll have to get creative to make this work - say any 70's & 80's parks?

[JohnnyBlazers]

[quote:fcd5c4edb2="honestiago"]Most of the '78 parks were still in use in the 80s. [b:fcd5c4edb2]How about we say the park has to actually be in use during the decade? [/b:fcd5c4edb2]Because I think there's a lot of decades without parks, and constraining managers to one park choice gives other managers an unfair advantage.[/quote:fcd5c4edb2]

I agree with you - let's go that route instead.

For the NEL teams and the lack of relievers - how about any relievers left over after the draft are fair game for the NEL teams only?

Regarding the CAP - I like the 100 Cap idea - I think going 120 will give the modern teams too much of an advantage in regards to power hitting vs. the earlier era teams, however, if we can get a consensus on this issue, we can go the way that the masses want.

[JohnnyBlazers]

1) 1800's-1910 - OakAth72
2) 1911-1919
3) 1920-1929 - PKBlack
4) 1930-1939
5) 1940-1949
6) 1950-1959
7) 1960-1969 - johnnyblazers
8) 1970-1979
9) 1980-1989
10) 1990-present - Modmark
11) Negro Leagues-I
12) Negro Leagues II

[honestiago1]

Already have a roster ready to go. :-) Now, which park, hmmm...

[JohnnyBlazers]

1) 1800's-1910 - OakAth72
2) 1911-1919
3) 1920-1929 - PKBlack
4) 1930-1939
5) 1940-1949
6) 1950-1959
7) 1960-1969 - johnnyblazers
8) 1970-1979
9) 1980-1989 - honestiago
10) 1990-present - Modmark
11) Negro Leagues-I
12) Negro Leagues II

[PotKettleBlack]

[quote:26e8267645="johnnyblazers"][quote:26e8267645="honestiago"]Most of the '78 parks were still in use in the 80s. [b:26e8267645]How about we say the park has to actually be in use during the decade? [/b:26e8267645]Because I think there's a lot of decades without parks, and constraining managers to one park choice gives other managers an unfair advantage.[/quote:26e8267645]

I agree with you - let's go that route instead.

For the NEL teams and the lack of relievers - how about any relievers left over after the draft are fair game for the NEL teams only?

Regarding the CAP - I like the 100 Cap idea - I think going 120 will give the modern teams too much of an advantage in regards to power hitting vs. the earlier era teams, however, if we can get a consensus on this issue, we can go the way that the masses want.[/quote:26e8267645]

Hrm: My 20's team.

Let's see. 120 allows me to use the 15M Ruth with pretty much roster impunity. I can put together a 100M roster minus a LF/DH/1B, then add Ruth and $5M. I like.

The 1909 and before all stars can put together a .400 hitting outfield/dh rotation at 120, with some legit shut down starters.

The 10-19... hrm. They might have problems at the 120. Probably not. Add pitching as some of the best pitchers in the set...

30's... hitting decade. No problem.

I wouldn't worry about the early teams keeping up. Maybe not in isoP, but in TB, I think they can hang. I know the Roaring 20s can.

[mrharryc]

Pursuant to a line in an episode of Green Acres, "there's nothin' as refreshin' as a good long depression," I'll take the 30's.


1) 1800's-1910 - OakAth72
2) 1911-1919
3) 1920-1929 - PKBlack
4) 1930-1939 - mrharryc
5) 1940-1949
6) 1950-1959
7) 1960-1969 - johnnyblazers
8) 1970-1979
9) 1980-1989 - honestiago
10) 1990-present - Modmark
11) Negro Leagues-I
12) Negro Leagues II