by Mean Dean » Fri Dec 09, 2011 12:33 am
Honestly, I think that particular "Golden Era" Veterans' Committee has now done its job and should be disbanded. Once you're choosing between Jim Kaat and Tony Oliva, you have run out of candidates (no offense to Minnesotans intended.)
The main omissions now (other than Marvin Miller and Bill James...) are mostly players from the "expansion" era. Lou Whitaker to me should clearly be in. Ted Simmons is also a strong candidate. The HOF does not do a good job dealing with positions that aren't 1B or corner OF. If a player has an argument that he is top 10-15 all-time at his position, then he should at the very least be getting significant support. The voters often ignore that.
None of these are nearly as bad snubs as Blyleven and Santo were, though. Those guys were above average even compared to the other Hall of Famers. It's rare, and an indictment of the quality of the voting, that such players had to wait as long as they did.