Here's an $80M ATG5 team where Kaline hit cleanup in an extreme pitchers park - hit .304/ .370/ .484, with nearly 120 RBI for a team that scored under 700 on the year.
Here are his numbers in an ATG 6 theme league (somewhat limited pool; tough competition), in Wrigley 41, for a team that won the championship. Looks like he's a good choice in extreme pitcher parks:
Kaline is a bit over priced as far as I am concerned,for less money K .Cuyler puts up simalar numbers and F.Alou hits for more power. For an extra million you get H.Aaron and he is a monster everywhere.