Not sure which way his card was tilted, but check out Rudy Pemberton's 1996 card. I believe his .512 batting average that year is the highest average SOM has ever carded.
You are right about Pemberton and the avg. Greg Jefferies had the card with the highest offensive output....until Bonds. But I'm talking strickly chances to reach base...I think Fancona wins....vs. LHP.