Who do I nuke A. Smith or W. Wilson?

[CHRISTIANSTOUGH]

Playing in the Astrodome v. Grifith; Yankee '39, and Crowsley '40

I have Culyer and D. Dimagio

but I also have W. Wilson and A. Smith.

I don't know Smith, but I like his arm and OBP and the fact that Culyer could play left if I keep him.

I like Wilson for his avg, speed and his D, but he has to play Left and his Arm isn't as good as Culyers

Is A. Smith a bum, or are his numbers good for Astrodome?

[Free Radicals]

Given the choices I'd take Wilson . He also doesn't get hurt and will play 162 games . Willie doesn't steal bases unless he's in the leadoff spot . He can hit both sides also , that 3L is decieving. His 1 arm isn't all bad either in LF .

[modmark46]

Got to agree with Wilson. Although some platoon him, he isn't THAT bad vs RHs. Not great OBP when facing RHs, but he usually ends up hitting at or near .300 for me, when I use him. Once in awhile, he will put together a nice .300 + season.

[Play By The Rules]

I have to vote for Smith. Underused, and underrated.

The exception would be if you have a ton of lefty bats and need some protection, Wilson is better vs. LH, Smith is better vs. RH.