Trade off for Ty Cobb

[wsrb]

[url]http://fantasygames.sportingnews.com/baseball/stratomatic/atg2/team/team_other.html?user_id=111538[/url]

Being offered a trade that includes Cobb. Is it a good idea to do it.
I am in Dodger Stadium 77.
1. Cobb, Weiss, Bahnsen for Leibold, Banks, Dreisewerd.

2 Ott for Cobb

Any thoughts! Thanks

[MICHAELTARBELL]

I have one rule of thumb....NEVER TRADE COBB!! :wink:

Ott is certainly no upgrade, and although Banks is a good player he is no Cobb....

my .02

[egvrich]

Definitely NOT Cobb for Ott ........ Banks is up to you.

[wellfleeter]

Mel Ott rules. Give me Cobb and you'll see.

[GCSluggers]

Cobb's #'s on my last team

AB R D HR RBI BB SB BA SLG OBP
Cobb, T. 692 156 51 20 90 67 73 .413 .606 .464


Can't argue with those numbers I would never trade Cobb

[Cruiser]

Cobb and Banks are pretty close. A lot depends on the other parks in your division and, obviously, the rest of your lineup. Both can post monster numbers on a regular basis.

Do not ever trade Cobb for Ott, unless maybe you're in a hitters park in a division full of hitters parks.

[raslavens]

Banks can be the better value, seeing as how a $3M RF is going to definitely hit better than a $3M SS. It's all about who you're replacing in your lineup.

In other words, give me Banks and Joe Jackson over Cobb and Cal Ripken.

[raslavens]

Banks can be the better value, seeing as how a $3M RF is going to definitely hit better than a $3M SS. It's all about who you're replacing in your lineup.

In other words, give me Banks and Joe Jackson over Cobb and Cal Ripken.

[Play By The Rules]

No way!

But you can do better than Weiss at SS IMO...