by honestiago1 » Tue Jun 06, 2006 8:21 pm
Bill James wrote aboyt what he called "the index of self destructive acts," (which may or may not apply to Nolan's 8-16 year, but bear with me). He said that some pitchers had a tendency to do more things to hurt themselves (walks being one thing), and that Nolan, for all his greatness, suffered from a complete inability to give anything to ANY batters. Whether he faced Mario Mendoza or George Brett, Nolan tried to make perfect pitch after perfect pitch, when, in some cases perhaps, he'd-a been better off to've given in a little, grooved a fastball to a lowly hitter, and maybe let his defense help him. The exact opposite of this philosophy is best represented by Fergie Jenkins and Catfish Hunter, who, as James put it, few walks and had a firm commitment to strike one. They'd give up a few bombs every now and then, but they didn't do a whole lot to hurt themselves. Accdording to James, Quiz had the lowest index of SDA's, while Hershiser actually ranked kinda high.
(I think all this is fr. James' historical baseball abstract)