by The Turtle » Tue Jun 27, 2006 11:22 pm
[b:92ffebab12]Okay guys here is an outline of what happend[/b:92ffebab12]
[b:92ffebab12]First Frank posted this on June 24th at 3 pm[/b:92ffebab12]
Frank M
Display at Top 24 Jun 2006 15:15
Gentlemen, after looking who has been picked. I really do believe that DJL3737 meant to pick Johan Santana and not Julio Santana. We need a confirmation. If this was Splinter or Visick I could care less. Razz Laughing
[b:92ffebab12]We Stop the Draft [/b:92ffebab12]
Terry101
24 Jun 2006 17:59
I'm fine with repicking. It is possible he wanted to take Johan Santana. Lets find out and if that is the case, I will pick another player.
24 Jun 2006 18:11
I will be gone a few hours. Let me know if I have to drop Johan Santana and redraft. I will check in as soon as I get back.
Detroit-Tigers
Jun 2006 19:41 Send private message Reply with quote
I would just assume he meant Johan, drop and repick and lets get going.
The Turtle
24 Jun 2006 20:42
I agree he meant to take Johann this is a 100 mill league after all ....Terry needs to drop and repick
socalchiro
25 Jun 2006 12:33
So then Terry has got to drop Johan AND NOBODY else can pick him up.
If Terry has no problem with that, he can drop him and re-pick another player.
When djl gets back, he can drop Julio for Johan.
Thanks guys...gonna unpause the draft. And away we go again...
Proxy...Proxy...Proxy...(understand splinter?)
visick
[b:92ffebab12]In the other thread there are 5 posts which we tell Terry to repick and he doesnt ....after 21 hours passed from Frnaks inital post to visicks we restarted the draft without Terry ever dropping Johan despite us telling him too 8 times [/b:92ffebab12]
[b:92ffebab12]We finish the draft anad than DJL shows back up, he somehow had left enough proxies to get through the entire draft since he did not have access to a computer over the weekend, however we find out he wanted Johann after all [/b:92ffebab12]
[b:92ffebab12]We Than hear back from Terry despite after his intital post that he would drop him he does not post again for nearly 3 days and said this.[/b:92ffebab12]
I'm fine with any solution. I took Johan Santana when I saw he was available.
At the time I did not even know that DJL took the other Santana.
Then people pointed out that he probably made a mistake and drafted the wrong Santana, I agreed and said I would repick.
The draft was stopped, we waited and then the draft started up again, so I figured everything was ok. I would have dropped Johan if DJL said it was a mistake. As far as I know that never happened. What if I dropped him, then someone else picked him up. That would be stupid.
I was perfectly willing to repick, then after the draft is over, it comes up again. So, either commish rules or DJL takes another pick. I understand it was a mistake but why did the draft continue then? If DJL really is set on
Johan maybe we could work out a trade. I can't be sure a trade would work but I would be willing to look at it. What do others think? I want everthing to be fair and not have any bad feelings. Again, I would be happy with any fair decision.
[b:92ffebab12]
So here we are with a problem of how to fix this. The facts are [/b:92ffebab12]
DJL mispicked and we knew it.
We stopped the draft.
We tell Terry to repick.
He did not.
We restarted the draft knowing this was screwed up without anyone complaining.
I know I assumed Terry was risking it and sticking with Johan sicne he continued to pick.
After DJL's picks kept coming I figured I was wrong and he did want Julio after all.
Then we finished the draft.
Now we have a problem.
[b:92ffebab12]
We have some solutions [/b:92ffebab12]
1. We can make them BOTH repick and make Johann a free agent
2. Terry can repick
3. DJL can repick
4. We can go with my first option
"I had the idea today that they both put him a #1 on their draft list and let HAL decide who gets him, and let them each pick a player in place of him on Penn's site...it gives them an advantage of maybe getting 8 players out of the draft and also penalizes them by losing their #1 draft choice."
5. We can do my option but limit that picked player to under 3 million (a role player)
[b:92ffebab12]
I say we vote by PM so as not to offend anyone , if visick approves everyone please PM him (I'll be out after 2pm tomorrow so it cant be me) your response so he can rule on the decision fairly.
[/b:92ffebab12]
As for Detroit's situation personally I dont have a lot of sympathy there as the mistake was pointed out quickly and Detroit was able to fix it quickly , as also since i followed the draft i knew Wright was gone and never would have picked him before asking on this page .......however i would have never have taken Minute Maid personally as felt that was "off limits"
[/b]